Elephant Whisperers: Indian couple in Oscar-winning elephant film sue makers

OscarThe Elephant Whisperers / Netflix

A indigenous couple at the centre of an Oscar-winning Indian film has sued its makers, alleging mistreatment.

Elephant Whisperers tells the story of Bomman and Bellie as they care for an orphaned and injured baby elephant inside the Mudumulai Tiger Reserve in the southern Indian state of Tamil Nadu.

The Netflix film made history at the Oscars by becoming the first Indian production to win in the Best Documentary Short Film category earlier this year.

And it turned the caretakers, Bomman and Bellie, into overnight sensations. After the film’s success, they were felicitated by Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin, who presented them with a cheque of 100,000 rupees ($1,207; £949.4) each, along with a citation.

The two also met Prime Minister Narendra Modi when he visited the elephant camp in April.

But the couple has now sued the film’s director Kartiki Gonsalves and Sikhya Entertainment – the production company run by award-winning producer Guneet Monga – alleging that they were not compensated properly for their participation.

They have sought 20m rupees “as a gesture of goodwill” and said the money would take care of their housing as well as their needs in old age. It’s not clear when the case will be heard but the couple’s lawyers have told Indian media that they would continue fighting.

The filmmakers have denied the allegations. In a statement to BBC Tamil, the director and the producer said they had “deep respect” for all contributors of the story.

Gonsalves, who responded to a message on WhatsApp, added: “All the allegations made by Bomman-Bellie are false, there is no truth in their allegations.”

Shot in the stunning vistas of the Nilgiri mountains, The Elephant Whisperers follows Bomman and Bellie as they care for Raghu, an injured baby elephant who gets separated from his herd.

The couple belong to the Kattunayakan community, a tribal group that has been protecting the forest for generations.

The film was praised for highlighting their efforts at wildlife conservation as it featured moving scenes that showcased the bond forged between the animals and their human caretakers.

Bomman and Bellie

BBC Tamil

The couple sent a legal notice to the makers in June but it became public last month when they gave an interview to a YouTube channel.

The couple alleged that the makers made several promises to them at the time of the shoot which they failed to keep. This includes, buying them a house and providing financial support for participating in the documentary.

“Gonsalves met us and said she was going to make a short documentary on us. We had no idea that the film would win an award. We simply did what she said,” Bomman told BBC Tamil. “During the shoot, the director told us that she will build a house for us and get us a car.”

But when the couple checked their bank account, they realised they had not received the money, they alleged.

“We have not got anything except the 100,000 rupees given by the chief minister and a government job. Gonsalves did not fulfil her promises and she did not pay us either. She didn’t do anything for us,” Bomman said.

The couple also alleged they had to spend their own money to cover the expenses of the shoot and had lent a sum of 40,000 rupees to Gonsalves which she did not return – a charge she denied.

In their legal notice, a copy of which was accessed by BBC Tamil, Bomman and Bellie said they had not received fair benefits from the huge commercial gains made by Gonsalves, Monga and Sikhya Entertainment.

They added that their “skill, time and effort should be compensated proportionately at least after the roaring success of the documentary short film”.

Indian film producer Guneet Monga (L), protagonists of Oscar winning Documentary short "The Elephant Whisperers" Bellie (2L), Bomman (2R) and Indian filmmaker Kartiki Gonsalves pose with the Oscar during a press conference in Mumbai on March 23, 2023. (Photo

Getty Images

Last week, Gonsalves and Sikhya Entertainment issued a joint statement denying the allegations. “All claims made are untrue. We have a deep respect for all of the contributors of this story, and remain driven by the desire to create positive change,” they said.

In their statement to BBC Tamil, the makers added that the documentary raised awareness and had real impact on the community that took care of the animals. “The documentary’s success was a ‘moment of national pride’ that has brought widespread recognition for the work of mahouts like Bomman and Bellie,” they said.

This is not the first time Indian subjects of award-winning films have taken issue with its makers in the aftermath of the film’s success.

In 2021, directors Rintu Thomas and Sushmit Ghosh made a documentary on Khabar Lahariya, an all-women news service run mostly by editors and reporters from the most marginalised Dalit, Muslim and tribal communities.

The film was nominated at the 2022 Oscars. But a week before the ceremony, the media group distanced itself from the documentary, accusing the filmmakers of “distorting” its story – a charge the filmmakers denied.

BBC News India is now on YouTube. Click here to subscribe and watch our documentaries, explainers and features.

Presentational grey line

Read more India stories from the BBC:

Presentational grey line

Continue Reading

King’s second son ‘Than Aon’ makes merit at Wat Yannawa

King's second son 'Than Aon' makes merit at Wat Yannawa
Vacharaesorn Vivacharawongse, the second eldest son of His Majesty the King, visits Wat Yannawa in Bangkok’s Sathon district on Thursday to make merit. (Photo: Nutthawat Wichieanbut)

Vacharaesorn “Than Aon” Vivacharawongse, the second eldest son of His Majesty the King, made merit at Wat Yannawa in Bangkok’s Sathon district on Thursday, following his surprise arrival in Thailand on Sunday evening.

Vacharaesorn, 42,  arrived at the royal temple on Charoen Krung Road with his friends. They were welcomed by Phra Tham Wachiramolee, abbot of Wat Yannawa, and Phra Khru Arthornprasittisophon, assistant abbot.  

Many Thai and foreign media members waited in the temple compound to cover him. Thai people who heard about his visit flocked to the temple to welcome him.

Vacharaesorn lit a candle and incense sticks to pay respect to Buddha statues and then gave food offerings to 130 Buddhist monks and novices at the temple’s Dhamma learning school. The abbot then presented him with a replica of Phra Sampao Yannawa, a 16-inch Buddha statue.

Than Aon, fondly called by Thais, then went to the temple’s pier along the Chao Phraya River to make merit by  releasing 1,000 fish into the river. He paid tribute to the monument of His Majesty King Nangklao (Rama III) before leaving the temple.  

Vacharaesorn is on a visit to the kingdom after living abroad for 27 years.

Vacharaesorn Vivacharawongse offers food to a novice at Wat Yannawa in Sathon district, Bangkok, on Thursday. (Photo: Nutthawat Wichieanbut)

He reportedly departed from the John F Kennedy airport in the United States on Aug 5 on board a Cathay Pacific flight to Hong Kong, where he took a connecting flight that landed at Suvarnabhumi airport in Samut Prakan province on Sunday evening. It was reported that he would stay in the country for about a week.

Upon his arrival, he paid respect to the Supreme Patriarch at Wat Ratchabophit Sathitmahasimaram Ratchaworawihan in Phra Nakhon district on Monday morning and then paid homage to the City Pillar before moving on to Wat Phra Kaew, or Temple of the Emerald Buddha, and Wat Hong Rattanaram Ratchaworawihan.

He also visited a childcare centre for underprivileged children in Bangkok and donated necessary items to the centre.

Vacharaesorn, who holds both bachelor’s and master’s decrees in law from Stetson University College of Law in the US, is second of the four sons of His Majesty the King and his former consort Sujarinee Vivacharawongse. Their younger sister is Her Royal Highness Princess Sirivannavari Nariratana Rajakanya.

Vacharaesorn on Wednesday posted photos with children at the Foundation for Slum Child Care (FSCC) in Bangkok with a message “The value of heritage comes from its inheritors.” Great pleasure to support FSCC. (Photo: Vacharaesorn Vivacharawongse’s Facebook)

[embedded content]

Continue Reading

Earthquake, tragedy & triumph – Japan to shine again?

Date: Friday, 11 August Kick-off: 08:30 BST Venue: Eden Park, Auckland
Coverage: Watch live on BBC One from 08:00 BST, BBC iPlayer and the BBC Sport website & app. Listen on 5 Sports Extra and BBC Sounds. Live text, analysis and report on the BBC Sport website.

“I was watching it on television at home,” Japan boss Futoshi Ikeda recalls when asked about memories of his nation’s 2011 Women’s World Cup triumph.

“The Japanese earthquake had just happened, so in that sense it was a tournament that gave everyone courage, and conveyed the joy and the greatness of sport.”

Japan’s momentous triumph in Germany 12 years ago was as emotional as it was unexpected.

Three months before the tournament, a devastating earthquake and tsunami along the country’s north-east coast killed more than 18,000 people, displaced tens of thousands and generated a tsunami which caused a nuclear meltdown at the Fukushima power plant.

The J-Village, Japan’s national football centre, was in Fukushima and became a place of refuge in the aftermath of the tsunami.

Japan defender Aya Sameshima was working at the nuclear plant at the time of the disaster and was recovering from the terrible events along with the rest of the squad which flew to Germany, including Saki Kumagai.

Aged 20 at the time, Kumagai struck the winning kick against the USA after the final had gone to a nail-biting penalty shootout at Frankfurt’s Waldstadion as the “Nadeshiko” – named after a delicate pink carnation – embodied the unbreakable spirit of a nation united in its battle to recover from disaster.

Twelve years on, Kumagai, 32, is Japan’s captain at the World Cup in Australia and New Zealand.

The Nadeshiko face Sweden, the nation they defeated in the semi-finals in 2011, in Auckland on Friday (08:30 BST kick-off) for a place in the last four.

“After we won the World Cup, a lot of girls started playing football,” Kumagai, who has played for her country since 2008 and is appearing at her fourth World Cup, said.

“Now the sport is less popular again and that’s not good. Our national team hasn’t won a lot recently and the Japanese people are less interested in the sport again.”

With Japan two wins from a third World Cup final in four attempts, will the class of 2023 go all the way and capture the hearts of the nation once again?

Japan's players hold up a banner after winning the 2011 Women's World Cup

‘Japan look unstoppable’

Japan have slipped from fourth to 11th in Fifa’s rankings since they last appeared at a World Cup final in 2015, when the USA avenged their 2011 defeat by winning 5-2 in Vancouver, Canada.

But they are playing with a freedom and a spirit that has left some tipping them to lift the World Cup in Sydney on 20 August.

“They look unstoppable,” Eniola Aluko, the former England forward, said on ITV1 following Japan’s 3-1 win over Norway in the last 16.

“These players are at the height of their confidence – the chemistry, the flow, the timing. They are really looking like an unbeatable team. How do you stop Japan now?”

In a World Cup that has been unpredictable, Ikeda’s team have remained solid – and exciting.

They have scored 14 times in four matches – their most in a single edition of the tournament – to sweep aside Zambia (5-0), Costa Rica (2-0), Spain (4-0) and Norway (3-1).

While former winners the USA, Germany and Norway have made early exits, Japan have marched on.

In Hinata Miyazawa, they have the tournament’s leading scorer. Despite registering only six attempts on target, Miyazawa has five goals.

Forward Mina Tanaka has three assists to add to her two goals, goalkeeper Ayaka Yamashita has conceded once in four games, while only Spain’s Teresa Abelleira (17) has created more chances than 19-year-old Aoba Fujino (11).

Japan has nurtured generation after generation of talented players in the women’s game. Ikeda’s current crop are showing they have the potential to surprise after indifferent form leading up to the tournament, including defeat to Denmark.

“This team has changed minds [at this World Cup],” Midori Masujima, a prominent Japanese sportswriter, told the BBC World Football podcast. “We have a confidence which is good.”

‘I felt Japan smile’

More than a decade on, some 31,000 people remained displacedexternal-link as a result of the earthquake and tsunami.

“I felt the whole of Japan smile,” the tearful mother of Japan captain Homare Sawa told Fuji Television after the win in 2011.

Meanwhile, United States goalkeeper Hope Solo said of Japan’s victory: “I truly believe that something bigger was pulling for this team.”

Tearful Japan coach Norio Sasaki revealed he had used images of the disaster to help motivate his players during the tournament.

Sasaki, who left in 2016, is in New Zealand, where the Nadeshiko have played all four of their games, as part of Japan’s World Cup delegation.

On Thursday, current Japan boss Ikeda said support from back home was helping inspire his players at the World Cup.

“The people in Japan watching us on TV, this support is something we really feel,” added Ikeda, who was in charge of Japan when they won the Under-20 Women’s World Cup in 2018.

A ship which was destroyed and pushed up on the land by the earthquake and tsunami that hit Japan in 2011
Cars which were destroyed by the earthquake and tsunami that hit Japan in 2011

Top of the world again?

Ikeda has fully utilised his 23-player squad by starting 17 different players in Australia and New Zealand.

Only four have started all the games so far – including West Ham defender Risa Shimizu, who scored against Norway in the last 16.

A further three Women’s Super League-based players have appeared in Japan’s midfield at this tournament including Liverpool’s Fuka Nagano, Shimizu’s West Ham team-mate Honoka Hayashi and Manchester City’s Yui Hasegawa.

As a young teenager, Nagano was inspired by the 2011 World Cup triumph and, speaking in Auckland, said she and her team-mates fully believed that this year’s Nadeshiko will be able to match the feat.

“I was 13 years old or so,” Nagano, 24, recalled on Thursday. “Back then, I saw how the Nadeshiko played and that really empowered me, that’s what I remember about it.

“The Nadeshiko won the World Cup and we want to show Japan’s strength again at this tournament. We all believe that we can do it, and I think that’s what has brought us to where we are now.”

Liverpool and Japan midfielder Fuka Nagano at a news conference at Eden Park, Auckland, on Thursday

Asked what impact the 2011 World Cup win had on her growing up as a 14-year-old, Hasegawa said: “It was tremendous.

“It was something that had an unbelievably huge impact on Japan after the disaster. It [winning the World Cup] made me more determined to do the same thing one day.”

Will Hasegawa achieve her dream later this month?

“We want to fight hard every match and aim to reach the top of the world again,” added Ikeda.

Continue Reading

US racing to close growing missile defense gaps

The US is racing to develop its next-generation homeland missile defense system as China, Russia and North Korea field new, sophisticated types of missiles capable of punching through existing US defenses. 

This month, Breaking Defense reported that US defense contractors Lockheed Martin and Northrop Grumman are accelerating the Next-Generation Interceptor (NGI) development with plans to shave months off their earlier production schedule to develop a prototype by 2027. 

A Lockheed Martin spokesperson said that the company has validated all the design elements of its Next-Generation Interceptors with the US Missile Defense Agency (MDA) on an accelerated schedule, according to the report. The spokesperson said Lockheed Martin has been consistently on track to deliver its prototype by 2027. 

On August 7, Lockheed Martin announced that, following successful subsystem reviews, the company is gearing up for an “all up round” preliminary design review this quarter. 

The report indicated the MDA will assess if Lockheed Martin’s designs are ready for the critical design review phase. For Northrop’s part, the company finished the systems requirements review three months ahead of schedule and is now aiming for a two-month preliminary systems review. 

The Breaking Defense report notes that the move accelerates the critical design review process to the end of 2024 from early 2025. Breaking Defense also reported that Northrop has produced the initial batch of solid-fuel rocket cases for the program. 

The report notes that these cases will be filled with inactive propellants and transported to Redstone Arsenal in Alabama, where they will be combined with an interceptor. 

After that process, Northrop will continue pathfinder activities and further validate the process, noting that the interceptor will undergo further testing and process verification once the integration process is completed.

Patty-Jane Geller notes in a March 2023 article for the Heritage Foundation think tank that unlike the older Ground-Based Interceptor (GBI), which was declared operational in 2003, the NGI will include multiple kill vehicles to intercept multiple objects such as warheads and decoys coming from one missile.

Geller also notes that the NGI is designed as a single system explicitly for missile defense, in contrast to the GBI, which was rushed into service due to operational needs and employed parts initially designed for other missions, adding complexity to maintenance and upgrades. 

Ultimately, Breaking Defense says the MDA plans to buy 20 NGIs starting in 2028 to augment the current GBI. 

Asia Times notes that, as of 2021, the GBI is a significant component of the US Ground-Based Midcourse Defense (GBD), the only US system defending all 50 US states against a limited intercontinental ballistic missile (ICBM) attack from China, Russia or North Korea. China and Russia can credibly currently threaten the US while North Korea is actively developing ICBMs to break the logic of US extended deterrence on the Korean Peninsula.

China’s solid-fuel DF-31 ICBM family poses a severe strategic risk to the US. Missile Defense Advocacy Alliance (MDAA) notes that the modernized DF-31A variant, which entered service in 2007, is a road-mobile and silo-capable design with a projected range greater than 11,000 kilometers, giving it the potential to strike all areas of the US, Europe and Russia. 

MDAA mentions that, unlike the older DF-31, the DF-31A conceals its warhead under a shroud and reportedly employs penetration aids, including at least eight decoy warheads. 

It also says that a newer variant, the DF-31B, is reportedly under development. MDAA says that the DF-31 reduces the ICBM technology gap between the US, China and Russia, with its MIRV capabilities having the potential to defeat US missile defenses. That, in turn, may give China strategic cover against US intervention during a Taiwan contingency.  

Similarly, MDAA notes that Russia’s RS-28 Sarmat, which was first commissioned in 2010, can strike targets 10,000 kilometers away with between 10-16 MIRVs and possibly 24 YU-74 hypersonic glide vehicles in the future. 

MDAA notes that the RS-28 serves both symbolic and strategic functions for Russia, underscoring its status as a nuclear power on par or more advanced than the US, which is still belatedly modernizing its nuclear arsenal. 

MDAA also notes that the RS-28’s capability to carry hypersonic weapons has the potential to make current-generation missile defenses such as the GBI obsolete. 

Alexander Ward claims in a February 2023 article for Politico that North Korea may already have enough ICBMs to overwhelm US missile defenses, noting that it unveiled 10 to 12 Hwasong-17 ICBMs during a military parade that month. 

Ward also mentions that the Hwasong-17 can theoretically hit the US from North Korea, although he says Pyongyang has yet to demonstrate that capability. 

More pointedly, he notes that the US has just 44 GBIs to intercept a potential limited ICBM attack from North Korea, but if it can fit four MIRVs into each Hwasong-17, Pyongyang can launch more nuclear warheads than the US has interceptors. 

Given China, Russia and North Korea’s missile advances, the GBD may no longer be an effective defense against ICBM attacks. In a September 2020 Breaking Defense article, Lockheed Martin explained why the long-serving system is overdue for a replacement, which it said is unfit to defend the US from ICBM threats from the 2030s and beyond. 

Underscoring that fact is the GBD’s low success rate in testing. Missile Threat noted back in 2017 that out of 30 GBD tests since 1997, 17 of which were intercept tests involving a target ballistic missile, only nine of the 17 hit their mark, resulting in a success rate of just 53%. 

Lockheed Martin notes that the most recent attempt to modernize the GBD was the Redesigned Kill Vehicle (RKV), initiated in 2015. However, the program was canceled due to engineering flaws resulting in multi-year delays and hundreds of millions of dollars in cost overruns. 

Lockheed Martin says that reusing standard technologies that were not designed for space use has resulted in the need to overhaul completely most related flight systems.

Continue Reading

Commercial diving firm fined S5,500 for flouting stop-work order; lives put ‘at risk’

SINGAPORE: A commercial diving company has been fined S$115,500 (US$85,697) for failing to comply with a stop-work order issued in October 2018, the Ministry of Manpower (MOM) said on Thursday (Aug 10). The firm was fined on Jul 14, 2023.

Joint Pacific Ocean Underwater Services (JPO) was issued a stop-work order on Oct 21, 2018, following an MOM inspection on board the dive boat JPO Challenger.

Companies that have been issued a stop-work order are not allowed to carry out workplace activities until safety measures have been taken to the satisfaction of the commissioner of Workplace Safety and Health.

The ministry said it found “several safety lapses”, including the lack of commercial diving equipment, the lack of a commercial diving training and the lack of a dive plan.

“Commercial diving activities could not be carried out as it would endanger the safety, health and welfare of workers,” MOM added.

However, the ministry later received feedback of possible infringement of the Work Safety and Health Act. It conducted follow-up inspections on Apr 25, 2019.

It was later found that JPO continued commercial diving activities even though the stop-work order was still in force.

For instance, the company made a total of 155 applications to the Maritime and Port Authority (MPA) for diving permits to carry out commercial diving operations.

Divers employed by JPO were also instructed to carry out commercial diving works, such as underwater inspections of vessels, underwater polishing of vessel propellers and underwater cleaning of vessel hulls.

“MOM uncovered 33 service reports containing details of works carried out,” it said.

“JPO had put the lives of its divers at risk by instructing them to carry out commercial diving works while the SWO was still in force.”

CNA has reached out to JPO and MPA for comments.Continue Reading

China opens up to more destinations for outbound group tourism

BEIJING: China is resuming outbound group tourism to destinations including Japan, South Korea, Australia, the United States, Germany and Britain, its culture and tourism ministry said on Thursday (Aug 10). The news cheered China’s outbound travel operators, which have struggled since 2020 with more than three years of pandemic-induced borderContinue Reading

Chatthaipattana joins Pheu Thai-led coalition

Chatthaipattana joins Pheu Thai-led coalition
Pheu Thai Party leader Cholnan Srikaew, centre right, announces the inclusion of the Chartthaipattana Party to its coalition alliance, at the parliament on Thursday morning. Representatives of both parties were present including Chartthaipattana leader Varawut Silpa-archa, centre left. (Photo: Chanat Katanyu)

The Pheu Thai Party has welcomed the Chatthaipattana Party, along with its 10 MPs, into its coalition, raising the number of House seats held by the coalition to 238 out of the total 500.

Both parties on Thursday morning expressed their commitment to seeking cooperation from all political parties and the Senate for the election of a new prime minister and the formation of a new government.

Pheu Thai leader Cholnan Srikaew said during a joint statement at the parliament that the country is in a unique political situation and all parties needed to join forces to address constitutional issues, economic challenges and social conflicts.

The two parties urged the public to have confidence in their alliance, which is intended to bring the Thai society back to normal quickly.

Chartthaipattana leader Varawut Silpa-archa said he thanked Pheu Thai for inviting his party to the coalition. Chatthaipattana was happy to accept the invitation and become a coalition partner, he said.

Mr Varawut cited shared policies and perspectives between Pheu Thai and Chartthaipattana and expressed confidence in Pheu Thai’s potential to lead the upcoming administration.

With the inclusion of Chartthaipattana, the Pheu Thai-led coalition alliance now consists of nine parties. Earlier Pheu Thai withdrew from its previous eight-party coalition with the May 14 general election winner Move Forward Party (MFP). The MFP had 151 House seats while Pheu Thai came second with 141 seats.

Pheu Thai later teamed up with the Bhumjaithai Party, which came third in the election with 71 House seats. On Wednesday Pheu Thai announced its coalition had six more political parties.

In the press conference, Pheu Thai leader Cholnan said that the previous eight-coalition alliance with Move Forward with a total of 312 House seats failed to form a government despite the best efforts from Pheu Thai.

Tne Pheu Thai-led coalition would have a majority vote in the 500-seat House before the parliament vote for prime minister, said Mr Cholnan.

Pheu Thai deputy leader Phumtham Wechayachai said Pheu Thai representatives’ meeting with the election-winning Move Forward Party (MFP) on Wednesday was not an invitation for the MFP to join the coalition government. Paetongtarn Shinawatra, a Pheu Thai prime ministerial candidate and daughter of fugitive former prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra, also attended the meeting.

Continue Reading