Turkey: the merciful end of Erdoganomics

Is the tide finally turning for Turkey? Three months after the re-election of Recep Tayyip Erdogan for his third term as president, which many feared would lead to economic chaos, ratings agency Moody’s has indicated that Turkey’s credit rating is on course for an upgrade.

Since the election, Erdogan has installed a new economic team with a commitment to reintroduce conventional monetary policies after years of a more singular approach. This has yielded some early positive results, with June recording the first current account surplus in 18 months – meaning more money came into the country than went out (mostly due to tourism and lower energy imports).

Meanwhile, Turkey’s stock market has been attracting surging interest from foreign investors, and the cost of insuring against the risk of the government defaulting on its debts has sharply declined. So what’s going on?

The mess

When Erdogan won the May election, contrary to the opinion polls, it extended his tenure as prime minister and then president to almost 20 years. This five-year term is likely to be his last, due to his deteriorating health and constitutional constraints. Thanks to the economic debacle that he created himself, it is also likely to be his most challenging.

There are two pillars to Erdoganomics: the “unorthodox” view that high interest rates cause inflation rather than the other way around, and a fixation on keeping rates as low as possible. It became much easier for him to implement after becoming executive president in 2018, which gave him much more power.

Central bank governors who have disagreed with Erdogan’s agenda have been shown the door, most notably Naci Agbal, who was sacked in March in 2021 after only four months in office.

It was the next governor, sahap Kavcıoglu, a former MP in the ruling party and columnist in a pro-Erdogan newspaper, who put Erdoganomics into overdrive. Turkey experimented with aggressively cutting rates at a time when inflation was already close to 20% and most central banks were tightening.

Official inflation skyrocketed to over 80% and the lira plummeted, forcing the central bank to sell substantial foreign exchange reserves to try and shore up the currency. The current account deficit widened to a record level in January and the earthquake in February further worsened the situation.

Turkish inflation and the falling lira

Graph showing inflation and TRYUSD
Graphic: Author provided via The Conversation

This all happened despite the fact that the authorities struggled to impose their interest rate cuts on the wider economy.

Whereas normally high-street interest rates move in line with the central bank rate, Turkish banks responded to the central-bank rate cut by increasing rates on consumer and business loans and savings accounts, signalling they didn’t think the central bank’s policy was sustainable.

Loan rates for businesses only later came down after the state-owned banks received a capital boost in the run-up to the election.

The interest rate divergence

Graph showing the difference between base and commercial rates in Turkey
Graphic: Author provided via The Conversation

A new approach?

The president has now taken a different path. He has appointed former investment banker Mehmet SimSek as finance minister. SimSek is respected by the markets due to a previous successful stint managing Turkey’s economy between 2007 and 2018. He has vowed to return to rational economic policies, announcing: “We will prioritise macro financial stability.”

Another reversal signal has been the appointment of Hafize Gaye Erkan as the first female governor of Turkey’s central bank. She too comes from investment banking, having formerly been managing director at Goldman Sachs and co-CEO of First Republic Bank in the US. She has no central banking experience, but markets nonetheless welcomed her appointment. She has an outstanding resume compared to her predecessor, Kavcıoglu.

Erkan hiked rates on June 22 from 8.5% to 15%, the highest in nearly two years. The accompanying press release expressed a clear view that this is the way to reduce inflation.

The lira has nevertheless kept losing value, while annual inflation rose from 38% to 48% in July. But along with the other improvements I mentioned at the beginning, there has also been a slight improvement in foreign exchange reserves, indicating that the central bank is under less pressure to defend the currency.

In July, the markets were further reassured by the appointments of high-profile economists as new deputy governors for the central bank. This further decreased Turkey’s credit risk. On July 20, the bank hiked interest rates again, to 17.5%.

What next?

Raising interest rates may have side effects. Turkey has one of the world’s highest percentages of “zombie firms” that have only been able to stay afloat because of low borrowing costs, so there could well be bankruptcies. Also, we know from the recent US banking failures that rate hikes inflict significant stress on banks by reducing the value of their bond portfolios.

Turkey’s banks are obviously not new to life under Erdogan. They have some fine management teams and effective risk-management practices that are used to weathering the country’s economic storms.

All the same, they look vulnerable because they hold low-yielding government bonds that could be impaired by aggressive rate hikes – particularly since they are denominated in lira, which creates exposure to further currency collapses. The government could alleviate this concern by swapping these bonds in exchange for new high-yielding ones.

The bigger question is whether we’re really seeing the end of Erdoganomics or just a lull. We can’t rule out a repeat of 2021, when Agbal was installed as central bank governor despite his orthodox economic views, then removed shortly after.

Erdogan has already put Sahap Kavcıoglu, his biddable governor from 2021-23, in charge of Turkey’s banking watchdog, which doesn’t suggest a total break from the past and has confused markets.

The danger is that Erdogan won’t allow interest rate hikes in the run-up to the local elections in March 2024. On the other hand, voters in cities such as Istanbul and Ankara have been severely affected by inflation. They overwhelmingly voted against Erdogan in the presidential election, having already handed metropolitan control to the opposition in 2019.

The Turkish lira collapsed while inflation surged. Image: Twitter

To regain these cities, Erdogan must tame inflation and alleviate the cost of living crisis. He may also be motivated by a desire to hand a better economy to his preferred successor (likely to be either his son or son-in-law), who might not enjoy his levels of popularity.

Whatever happens, much damage has already been done. The nation’s current GDP per capita is US$10,616, well below its peak of $12,508 in 2013 (albeit it has grown for the past couple of years). Turkey has lost significant numbers of skilled workers to other countries.

Halting this brain drain, or even reversing it, will be crucial for future economic growth. This seems unlikely under Erdogan’s leadership. Avoiding a financial crisis is only the first step forward.

Cem Soner is Doctoral Researcher in Finance, Bangor University

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Continue Reading

Japan, South Korea strengthen security ties amid signs of thawing relations long strained by wartime history

JAPAN’S DEFENCE POLICY

Since taking office in October 2021, Mr Kishida has shifted Japan from its long-held pacifist policy.

Tokyo unveiled a record budget for its biggest post-war defence expansion last December.

Under the new security and defence policy, the nation will be allowed to launch preemptive attacks on aggressors.

Mr Kishida’s government, in its annual defence paper released last month, cited China’s growing assertiveness in the region, as well as North Korea’s military activities, as major concerns for Japan.

Observers said the threats from neighbouring powers have prompted the nation – which has for decades depended on the US for security – to start stepping up its own defence capabilities and forging defence alliances.

Public opinion polls show that an increasing number of Japanese support the build-up.

However, the public stopped short at backing Mr Kishida’s attempts to go a step further to export lethal weapons, a survey by Japanese news agency Jiji Press found.

Continue Reading

Rear-ended Rolls-Royce owner wants compensation

Rear-ended Rolls-Royce owner wants compensation
A screenshot from a video shows the B37 million Rolls-Royce Ghost stopped on Highway 7 after being rear-ended by an Isuzu pickup truck in Chachoengsao province on Sunday. (Photo supplied)

The owner of a 32-million-baht Rolls-Royce has denied reports she agreed to let off the pickup driver who rear-ended her car, causing damage estimated at one million baht.

She is seeking compensation.

Sun Yuhan, 38, a Chinese woman, filed her complaint with highway police on Wednesday.

She was at the wheel when her Rolls-Royce Ghost was rear-ended on Highway 7 in Bang Pakong district, Chachoengsao, on Sunday afternoon by an Isuzu pickup truck. She asked police to take legal action against the driver. There were no injuries in the accident.

Her lawyer Anirut Khongsap said his client owned restaurants in Bangkok and Pattaya. She was driving the car alone to Bangkok to have the vehicle checked at a garage when the accident occurred.

Both vehicles parked after the accident. She attempted to talk with the pickup truck driver.

“As she can’t speak Thai, she gestered with her hands for him to meet her later at the garage she was heading to,” the lawyer said.

“Due to miscommunication, the other side did not show up. She denies reports that she was not bothered by the accident. She was shocked by the reports and sought legal counsel,” Mr Anirut said.

He said the Rolls-Royce was covered by first-class insurance. However, the Chinese woman stood firm in asserting she was not at fault, so she filed a complaint with police and asked that they call in the pickup truck driver and charge him.

She denied reports that she had braked abruptly before the accident. The damage to the rear of her car was estimated at slightly over one million baht.

Pol Lt Col Sophon Komolsutthi, a deputy chief interrogator of highway police, received her complaint. He said the pickup driver did not attempt to flee and would report to police as ordered. Police would examine surveillance camera footage from the highway as part of their investigation.

The driver of the Isuzu pickup was identified only as Pongthep, aged 23. The man was quoted as saying that he and the woman talked through translation software, and that he understood her to say she was not bothered by the accident.

Continue Reading

Meeting on Thursday expected to set date for PM vote

Meeting on Thursday expected to set date for PM vote
Parliament president Wan Muhamad Noor Matha speaks to reporters. (Photo: Chanat Katanyu)

A meeting at the parliament on Thursday is expected to set a date for the next joint session to vote for a new prime minister.

The meeting will follow Wednesday’s rejection by the Constitutional Court of petitions by voters seeking to defend the right of Move Forward Party leader Pita Limjaroenrat to be renominated for prime minister on July 19, after he failed to get the needed support on July 14.

House Speaker Wan Muhamad Noor Matha, the ex-officio parliament president, said before the scheduled decision on Wednesday that the parliament would call a meeting of legal experts on Thursday to discuss a date for the next parliamentary vote for a new prime minister. The meeting would also consider the agenda for the debate.

Observers now expect the joint sitting to be either this Friday or next Tuesday, Aug 22.

Complainants in the case were all voters and included Assoc Prof Pornchai Theppanya and Assist Prof Boonsong Chalaythorn, who both voted for MFP in the May 14 general election. Another complainant was MFP MP Panyarat Pusitanont.

They filed their petitions with the court through the Ombudsman, complaining the parliament’s rejection of Mr Pita’s renomination affected their constitutional rights. 

The Ombudsman forwarded these complaints to the charter court last month.

The joint sitting on July 19 rejected Mr Pita’s renomination on procedural grounds, citing regulation 41 that  forbids the reintroduction of a failed motion during the same session, including the nomination of a prime minister. Mr Pita’s supporters argued that it applies to general business, not to the nomination of a prime minister.

On July 24, 115 law lecturers from 19 institutions also expressed their opposition to the parliament’s passing of the resolution on July 19 to block the renomination of Mr Pita.

Mr Wan delayed the prime ministerial vote on Aug 4 after the Constitutional Court postponed its ruling.

On an urgent motion raised by MFP MP Rangsiman Rome for parliament to review its July 19 resolution rejecting the renomination of Mr Pita, Mr Wan said he would ask parliamentary officials to prepare session procedures and invite the Senate and the House whips for a meeting before the next parliamentary session.

Continue Reading

‘This is what I want to do, mum’ – New Zealand’s World Cup legacy

“I’m really filled with hope,” says New Zealand women’s football fan Annie Kennedy. “There is belief that wasn’t there before. I see it as a huge success.”

New Zealand’s biggest sporting global party has finished.

With co-hosts Australia staging the second semi-final, third place play-off and final, the 29th and final Fifa Women’s World Cup match to be staged in New Zealand saw Spain defeat Sweden 2-1 in Tuesday’s semi-final at Eden Park.

Another 43,217 sell-out crowd watched as all three goals came in a dramatic final nine minutes before La Roja’s celebrations began after reaching the final for the first time.

A pulsating end to a five week festival of women’s football in New Zealand.

From Auckland to Wellington and Hamilton to Dunedin, crowds have clapped, cheered and marvelled at the skills of global stars like Alexia Putellas, Alex Morgan, Ada Hegerberg and Fridolina Rolfo.

Eden Park witnessed the first of many shocks at this unpredictable tournament when New Zealand’s Football Ferns defeated former world champions Norway on an unforgettable opening night on 20 July.

South Africa’s players sang and danced as they stepped off the team coach in Dunedin, while Japan’s left a ‘thank you’ message on a white board after cleaning their dressing room in Wellington.

But what impact has the Women’s World Cup had in New Zealand? And what does the future of women’s football in the country look like now teams have packed up and camera lights been dimmed?

The attendance of 43,217 is shown on the big screen at Eden Park, Auckland, for the Women's World Cup semi-final between Spain and Sweden

‘Never seen anything like it’

Michael Burgess is an experienced sports writer for the New Zealand Herald newspaper.

“We have never seen anything like this before and all of us realise we probably won’t see anything like it again,” he told the BBC World Football at the Women’s World Cup podcast.

“Football has taken over the country in an unprecedented way. We felt so lucky to get this tournament in the first place and, with the way women’s football is growing around the world, it probably won’t come back to Australasia.”

In a country with a population of just five million people, rugby and cricket dominates the sporting landscape in New Zealand.

Is football catching up?

“The Football Ferns took rugby off the back pages,” added Burgess. “Even after they were knocked out it just continued and it was something none of us really expected.

“It been an awakening for the sport – especially for the women’s side of the game.”

There are challenges ahead for New Zealand Football, the country’s governing body, as it looks to build on the success of the Women’s World Cup.

“There will be a lot of kids who have seen the Women’s World Cup who will say ‘this is what I want to do, mum’,” said Burgess.

“Are the clubs available? Are pitches available? Are coaches available? Another challenge is that we don’t have a women’s professional league in New Zealand.

“Netball is the massive female sport in this country. I can certainly see a migration from sports like netball and hockey and other traditional female sports into football. If you get the numbers, that starts to pay off in so many ways.”

A thank you message is seen on the white board in Japan's dressing room in Wellington at the 2023 Fifa Women's World Cup

‘Starved of football’

Before the World Cup, the record crowd for football match in New Zealand was 37,034 for a men’s World Cup play-off against Peru in Wellington in 2017.

Despite early concerns about ticket sales, that record has been shattered three times at Eden Park, New Zealand’s national stadium, during this tournament.

After 42,137 witnessed Hannah Wilkinson’s winner for the Football Ferns against Norway in Auckland, 42,958 turned up to see the USA held 0-0 by Portugal on 1 August. Four days later that sell-out crow of 43,217 witnessed Spain thrash Switzerland 5-1 in the last 16 – the biggest stadium crowd for a sporting event in New Zealand this year.

Eden Park was also sold-out for the quarter-final between Japan and Sweden on 11 August and Tuesday’s semi-final.

Around 80% of the ticket sales for Eden Park have been to people living in New Zealand.

“This tournament has seen a colossal change in the way football and particularly women’s football is seen in New Zealand,” Andrew Pragnell, CEO of New Zealand Football, said.

“Football is already the biggest and the fastest growing organised team sport in the country and this tournament, as well as the numerous legacy programmes we have established, will supercharge it.”

More than 700,000 fans watched the 29 World Cup games in New Zealand, with Wellington Regional Stadium hosting nine matches.

“It seemed like a distant dream in the dark days of Covid,” Shane Harmon, CEO of Wellington Regional Stadium, said.

“Any concerns prior to the tournament about whether Kiwis would get behind this event in sufficient numbers have been firmly put to rest.”

Nick Sautner, CEO of Eden Park, which also hosted nine matches, said Kiwis had been “starved of football content” before the World Cup.

“The atmosphere at Eden Park has been electric, with colour and culture celebrated through the beautiful game,” he added.

New Zealand coach Jitka Klimkova talks to young fans of the Football Ferns during the 2023 Women's World Cup

‘Massive jump in numbers’

When New Zealand was named co-hosts for the Women’s World Cup in June 2020, there were no professional women’s football teams in the country.

Since the announcement, Wellington Phoenix have joined Australia’s A-League Women.

They play their home games at Wellington Regional Stadium, one of 10 venues used at the World Cup.

“Not long ago we had about 11 girls at the academy. Now we’re getting emails every day from girls who dream of becoming professional players,” Katie Barrott, female development lead at Wellington Phoenix academy, told the BBC World Football podcast.external-link

While there is disappointment here that New Zealand failed to advance from their World Cup group, the Football Ferns managed four points from three games – more than in their previous five World Cup campaigns combined (3).

“Everybody is talking about the Football Ferns,” said Paul Temple, Wellington Phoenix women’s head coach.

“Everyone knows who they are and we’ve now got domestic role models for our young girls to look up to.

“I heard [England’s] Leah Williamson talk about when she was growing up and not having those female players to see every week on television. It was the male players who were the heroes.

“I’m sure we’re going to see a massive jump in numbers of young girls wanting to play after this World Cup.

“We’ll hopefully see the effects of that swell in three of four years time. That legacy is so important.”

A young New Zealand fan shows her support for the Football Ferns at the Fifa Women's World Cup

Will World Cup leave lasting legacy?

Charli Dunn is a 16-year-old centre-back for Auckland-based club Western Springs, whose facilities were used by Norway.

She has to actively promote football to her friends.

“Especially girls’ football, you have to promote that a lot over boys football, rugby or something,” she said.

“But I think most people are kind of getting more into the football because the World Cup’s been here.”

Caleb Ward, interim women’s coach at Western Springs, added: “I think women’s soccer has a really bright future.

“To see New Zealanders start to embrace it is really cool, and hopefully we get the knock-on effect of more people participating.”

Across the BBC bannerAcross the BBC footerContinue Reading

Wife-sharing drug rapes: Man testifies that wife had affair with the first man he sent to ‘test’ her loyalty

On Sep 2, 2010, O met J’s wife for lunch before taking her to a place suggested by J, where they had consensual sex. O’s credit card records reflect the corresponding transactions.

However, O did not tell J that he had consensual sex with J’s wife.

In court, J said that O was supposed to be giving him “accurate feedback” on what was happening, because J was meant to have the right to call a halt on any activities.

J soon suspected that something was going on between his wife and O.

On Oct 26, 2010, J went to Marina Bay Sands resort with his wife and he posted a photo online of himself with his wife at the infinity pool.

J said he checked his wife’s chatlogs on MSN, which she used to chat with people including O.

In one chat, he saw his wife telling O that when J asked for intimacy, she did not feel like responding to him, but would close her eyes and imagine that J was O.

After the staycation at Marina Bay Sands, J snooped on another chat where O asked J’s wife if she enjoyed her staycation, whether she swam, and whether she wore a bikini.

After this, J confronted his wife but not directly – he told her that a neighbour had seen her being intimate with another man.

J said he believed that the affair ended after this because his wife had blocked O on MSN.

On Mar 14, 2011, their third wedding anniversary, J drugged his wife and asked O over.

The series of events that occurred on this occasion was disputed by the prosecution and the defence.

The prosecution’s case was that O conspired with J for O to rape J’s drugged wife.

But when asked to recount what happened, J spoke in dribs and drabs without a clear narrative. He mentioned wanting to retaliate against his wife for “being unfaithful to me” and “for causing dishonour to me”.

When asked by Ms Lim if the purpose of O going over was to rape his wife, J said yes. But when asked how O knew this purpose, J said: “I believe he should know what is being discussed between me and my co-accused persons as well.”

J then said that he had only two “mental memories” of what happened that day – one of which involved him cleaning his wife up and crying, asking himself “What have I done”.

J had previously admitted that he felt a mix of “guilt and arousal” watching them, but now said that: “Until today, I cannot imagine myself standing there and (watching).”

PROSECUTION PRODUCES MESSAGES

The prosecution showed J some messages he exchanged with another co-accused, where J said he got a man to rape his wife on their third-year wedding anniversary.

J confirmed that this referred to O.

The prosecutor also showed J messages from a year later, in 2014, where O asked J if there was any “operation (J’s wife)”.

Asked to explain this operation, J said: “I’m a military guy. So he’s asking whether is there any operation (J’s wife) which is my wife, and the operation is referring to whether am I drugging my wife for the purpose to get other people to rape her.”

The men then discuss how to get J’s wife drugged so that the operation could be carried out.

They also discussed carrying out the act in the children’s room, while the children were asleep.

In other chats, O asked J what his back-up plan was if his wife suspected something.

J said he would “deny and act (as) if nothing happened” but said there would be “no return” if the other man was found in the house.

O suggested for J to say he had such a fetish, and to make sure all chat records were deleted.

“If she make police report, all die,” said O.

O is defended by lawyers Mr Chua Eng Hui, Ms Luo Ling Ling and Mr Joshua Ho. He appeared in court in a jacket and tie, and took down notes as the hearing progressed.

The trial continues. If convicted of abetment by conspiracy to commit rape, O could be jailed for up to 20 years and fined or caned.

Continue Reading

Srettha defends former firm’s land purchase

Pheu Thai PM candidate hits back at second set of allegations by whistleblower Chuvit

Srettha defends former firm's land purchase
The upscale condominium Khun by Yoo was built on a plot of land acquired by Sansiri Plc in the Thong Lor area of Bangkok. The company has denied claims of irregularities in the land transaction. (Photo: Sansiri Plc)

Srettha Thavisin, the prime ministerial candidate of the Pheu Thai Party, said on Wednesday that the property developer he formerly headed, Sansiri Plc, bought a land plot in inner Bangkok transparently at its market price.

He was responding to what SET-listed Sansiri has called “deliberate misinformation” spread by whistleblower Chuvit Kamolvisit that it made an illegal land purchase using nominees for its Khun by Yoo luxury condominium.

Mr Chuvit, a former massage parlour tycoon and politician, made the allegation on Tuesday. It was the second claim he had made about malfeasance at Sansiri while Mr Srettha served as its chief executive.

Mr Chuvit has claimed that unethical corporate behaviour allegedly approved by Mr Srettha made him an unsuitable candidate for prime minister. He is expected to be nominated in parliament by the Pheu Thai Party to head a new coalition government within the next few days.

Mr Chuvit alleged that Sansiri used a company in which a housekeeper and a security guard were the shareholders to purchase land in the Thong Lor area of Bangkok in 2016. He said the nominee company took out a 1-billion-baht loan to pay a landowner 565 million baht for the land. No one appears to know what the rest of money was spent on, he added.

The land plot was purchased at 1.1 million baht per square wah which was its market price, Mr Srettha wrote on his Facebook page on Wednesday.

In a statement to the Stock Exchange of Thailand, Sansiri also rejected allegations that the price paid to the seller, N&N Asset Co Ltd, had been misstated. The price reflected prevailing market values for the area, it added.

“It has been suggested that Sansiri purchased this plot of land at an inflated price and should have only paid 565 million baht for the plot, or 650,000 baht per square wah. This suggestion is baseless,” the statement said. “No landowners in Thong Lor would sell at this price.”

Mr Srettha also said that his three-decade-long management of Sansiri had been recognised for good corporate governance and he welcomed any investigation that was based on facts and good intentions.

On Tuesday, Mr Chuvit claimed that the name of a housekeeper had been used as a previous buyer of the land plot.

The 38-year-old woman, identified only as Pinit, denied her acknowledgement of any land deal. She said she had worked in Bangkok about five years ago and was stunned when she heard her name had been linked to a land transaction.

She denied she had worked as a housekeeper and said that she already informed police in her native province, Maha Sarakham, of her innocence.

Sansiri said its land purchasing procedures conformed to legal requirements. “Every step is transparent and accountable.”

The company also said that its subsidiary, Arnawat Co Ltd, was not an existing creditor of N&N Asset. In its statement to the SET, it attached a copy of the land mortgage contract that it filed with the Department of Land.

Mr Srettha is already suing Mr Chuvit for 500 million baht for defamation over earlier comments made about a land purchase by Sansiri on Sarasin Road in Bangkok.

In that transaction, Mr Chuvit alleged Mr Srettha and Sansiri colluded with the landowners to evade 521 million baht in taxes on the developer’s purchase of the prime site.

Sansiri responded that in any such transaction, the sellers are responsible for paying any taxes and that the company had no influence over their actions.

Continue Reading

China tech giants offer upside surprises

As Chinese Communist Party leaders gathered at the beach resort of Beidaihe in recent days, the many storm clouds on the horizon were impossible to ignore.

Between an economic slowdown, deflationary forces, new property market distress and ongoing hostilities with the West, Chinese leader Xi Jinping has a full slate of headwinds with which to contend.

Yet it’s worth noting key areas where Beijing is picking up potentially powerful tailwinds, too. Despite the various sources of turbulence, Chinese tech earnings are racking up some impressive gains.

From Ant Group making a net profit of 13.37 billion yuan (US$1.85 billion) in the three months to March 31, a 17.5% year-on-year jump, to Huawei reporting 2.2% year-on-year growth in consumer business revenue for the first half of the year, there’s reason for optimism that the worst may be over for China’s battered tech giants.

Such signs of hope are badly needed at a moment when US President Joe Biden’s White House is cranking up the punitive pressure on China’s tech firms, nominally in the name of US national security.

Last week, Team Biden banned US investors from investing in sections of China’s chips, quantum computing and artificial intelligence (AI) industries. The step could upend efforts to lift Sino-US ties from their historic lows. Team Xi might retaliate anew.

One interesting wrinkle surrounding this year’s Beidaihe confab is the theme of scientific and tech self-sufficiency.

To amplify the point, invites were extended to a large number of semiconductor and AI experts — at least 57 — on the “forefront of domestic technology.” Such invitations tend to shed light on the concerns that Beijing views as most urgent.

The official Xinhua news agency quoted Xi’s chief of staff Cai Qi saying “We hope all experts … make new and greater contributions to achieving high-level scientific and technological self-reliance.”

On the ground, though, there are myriad signs that China Inc is coming out the other side of the last few years of regulatory crackdowns on tech platforms — and showing convincing signs of life.

Take Alibaba Group reporting a 14% year-on-year jump in quarterly sales in the April-June period despite sputtering mainland economic growth.

Back in fashion?: Jack Ma playing to the crowd during a 20th anniversary event for Alibaba in Hangzhou. Photo: Asia Times Files / AFP / Strigner

All of the key business units of the e-commerce colossus Jack Ma built are returning to life and buttressing the argument that Xi’s wealth and confidence destroying clampdown is in the rearview mirror.

“Big tech earnings may show continued recovery, with profits expected to rise 10.4% year-on-year in 2Q,” says Marvin Chen, an analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence.

This was the pledge that Premier Li Qiang made in March when he became Xi’s No 2 official and financial reform enforcer.

News that the domestic commerce unit of Alibaba — ground zero of Xi’s tech clampdown in late 2020 — is now producing about $16 billion in revenue, a 12% rise year on year in Q2, seems indication enough that China’s Big Tech may be ready to shift into higher gear.

The bold corporate overhaul Alibaba announced in March is by all indications off to a solid start. China’s online commerce leader announced plans to split its $220 billion empire into six business units, a major restructuring that promises to yield several initial public offerings (IPOs).

The breakup frees up Alibaba’s main divisions from e-commerce and media to the cloud to operate with far more autonomy, laying the foundation for future spinoffs and market debuts that create fresh wealth and jobs.

The maneuver also offers a blueprint for other tech giants to navigate around regulators’ efforts to curb monopolistic behavior among internet platforms. As Neo Wang, analyst at Evercore ISI, puts it, the six-way split-up could “serve as a template for Alibaba’s peers.”

Since November 2020, when regulators clamped down on Ma’s empire, Baidu, Meituan, Tencent and a who’s-who of Big Tech names have felt the monopoly-curbing, regulatory heat.

Yet it was Ma’s Ant that bore the initial brunt of the market-shaking putsch. Beijing regulators pounced in particular on Ma’s plans to take his fintech unit public, a planned $37 billion IPO that would have been history’s biggest.

Rather than listing in New York, as Alibaba did in 2014, Ant was to sell shares in Shanghai and Hong Kong. The IPO had promised to raise the Greater China region’s status as a tech and finance superpower.

Now, as economic growth stalls and property woes dangerously fester, Team Xi needs to lean into these tech green shoots to strengthen the tailwinds coursing through the economy.

Since March, Premier Li has been linearly focused on catalyzing more scientific and technological innovation and affording the private sector more space to grow and create well-paid jobs.

According to Li’s plans, Beijing regulators are going easier on tech giants and supporting the development of micro, small and medium-sized enterprises (MSME) to address record youth unemployment, which hit a record 21.3% in June, without relying on large-scale stimulus.

Chinese Premier Li Qiang wants more private sector-led economic growth. Photo: Pool

China cut interest rates this week in a move that surprised many analysts and underscored the deepening depths of China’s economic troubles.

“The market was expecting the People’s Bank of China to wait until September before easing again, and [recent] cuts suggest that the authorities’ concern about the state of the macroeconomy is mounting,” says Robert Carnell, head of Asia-Pacific research at ING Bank, said.

A big piece of the economic revival puzzle is reversing Xi’s efforts to maintain the dominance of state-owned enterprises (SOEs). In the years since 2015, the year when Shanghai stocks collapsed, Xi’s response has been to support SOEs to boost economic growth.

Li’s charge now is to diversify the economy away from exports and smokestack industries, which ultimately means incentivizing greater private sector innovation and productivity.

The key will be for Xi to give Li the latitude to get his reform plans dating back to 2013 back on track. A decade ago, Xi pledged to let market forces play a “decisive” role in Beijing’s decision-making.

Since then, though, China has become less, not more, transparent, withholding key data needed for efficient market mechanisms. Indeed, Xi’s recent regulatory crackdowns and other restrictions on private business have made it harder and harder for outside credit ratings companies to assess where China Inc is headed.

Last month, Li said the government is stepping up efforts to normalize China’s regulatory environment. The goal, Li has said, is to “reduce the costs of compliance and promote the healthy development of industry.” He said that “on the journey of building a modern socialist country, the platform economy has great potential.”

In a speech in mid-July, Li told tech chieftains in the audience – including officials from Alibaba Group, TikTok owner ByteDance and food delivery group Meituan – to “push to increase their international competitiveness and dare to compete on the global stage.”

To analyst Kelvin Wong at OANDA, the latest rhetoric from the top man on China’s State Council is “likely to boost positive animal spirits in the short-term at least.”

But Team Xi also must work harder to pull in more foreign capital. “Inbound investment has fallen despite Premier Li’s best efforts to roll out the welcome mat for foreign executives and local government officials crisscrossing the globe in search of new sources of capital,” the Eurasia Group consultancy wrote in a note.

Eurasia Group points out that “multiple factors” have contributed to China’s failure to boost FDI.

“Cash-strapped local governments are unable to offer the generous subsidies and access to free land that they once did. The nationwide push for a ‘unified market’ increasingly discourages preferential treatment or discriminatory policies at the local and provincial levels,” the Eurasia Group report said.  

“Domestic firms are becoming formidable competitors in industries such as automaking, narrowing the opportunities for foreign firms in sectors that have attracted a large share of FDI in the past,” the same report said.

“Hawkish signals from Beijing over national security” – including a revised anti-espionage law that went into effect on 1 July – a crackdown on the activities of foreign consultancies and due diligence firms operating in the country, are also denting new FDI, the Eurasia Group said.

That, and other recent moves targeting select multinationals, “have contributed to a deepening anxiety among foreign companies, many of which are weighing China opportunities against third country alternatives as they try to ‘de-risk’ their supply chains in the face of rising geopolitical tensions,” the report said.

Yet recent signals from China’s top tech companies suggest better days lie ahead. Team Xi just needs to accelerate efforts to ensure the virtuous cycle continues.

Follow William Pesek on X, formerly known as Twitter, at @WilliamPesek

Continue Reading