CNA Explains: Should I wear a mask on a plane if it’s optional?

How safe is usually flying without a cover up?  

Although masks are usually optional on some flights, should you nevertheless wear one? Contagious diseases experts noted that ventilation requirements for planes are high, and that there have been no major COVID-19 clusters originating from flights.  

“Travelling in commercial airplane is much safer than people think, ” said Professor Dale Fisher, senior specialist at the National University or college Hospital’s Division of Infectious Diseases.  

The air inside a plane is transformed over every three minutes, he stated. About 60 percent of the air getting into the cabin is completely fresh and through outside, while the additional 40 per cent is usually passed through hospital-grade HEPA, or high-efficiency particulate air filters, which remove 99. 97 per cent of airborne particles.  

“This is why there have been no major groupings on planes. It is almost impossible for COVID particles to be wafting through a plane. And so i think it is reasonable to not wear a mask – unless of course you do have a respiratory infection, ” said Prof Fisher.  

Travellers also remove their particular masks when meals on the plane, this individual noted.  

By not within the mask throughout the trip and taking them off sometimes, they might be exposing by themselves to those around all of them during those intervals, said Prof Fisher, who is also Professor of Medicine on the NUS Yong Bathroom Lin School associated with Medicine.

An additional infectious diseases specialist, Dr Leong Hoe Nam, said the particular HEPA filters are “as good since it gets”.

Yet Dr Leong, exactly who runs a private practice at Mount Elizabeth Novena Hospital, mentioned transmission could nevertheless occur “three rows in front of and behind your seat”.

“Given that travellers in coach are packed close together, this does not give much comfort. Business class and first-class patients will be exposed as well. All you need is one patient, ” he told CNA.  

To prevent falling sick while on holiday, he suggested travellers to continue wearing a mask on flights even if it is optionally available.

Who ought to wear a mask while on an air travel?

Different people are at different levels of risk if they catch COVID-19, and this may influence their decision to wear a face mask on a flight, specialists said.  

For example , those who are young or who have retrieved recently from COVID-19 “may brave it”, said Dr Leong.  

Nevertheless , some reports suggest that people could catch COVID-19 again as early as 17 days after a prior infection, this individual said.  

Those who are more susceptible might choose to wear a mask in case their immunity is poor, Dr Leong stated. This could include transplant patients who are upon various immunosuppressive drugs, cancer survivors, or even if they are returning house to family members who are at higher risk.  

Professor Paul Tambyah, president of the Asia Pacific Modern society of Clinical Microbiology and Infection, recommended that travellers must do “whatever they are comfortable with”.

“For people who are immunocompromised or even who have not been infected before, it could probably be a good idea to use a mask through the flight although this can be uncomfortable, ” he added.  

“For those who are quadruple vaccinated and earlier infected, the risks of severe disease are really low, so this is up to them. ”