Singapore’s urban farming heights cast a shadow over traditional agriculture

You will find sweet potatoes overlooking Citibank.  

On the 51st floor of the CapitaSpring building in Singapore’s central business area a grass ceiling of crazy paving and edible crops turns the top from the commercial high-rise in to a salad of fresh greenery. Below the starfruit, Brazilian spinach and Daikon radish, office blocks and vibrant shipping storage containers line the Lion City’s busy harbour.

Singapore’s latest urban agriculture venture, a project by food security motion Edible Garden Town, became the world’s highest farm on its May start, toppling Paris’s Expo Porte de Versaille from the podium.   Since then, the Oughout. K. has already introduced plans to your edible rooftop competition with a proposed Bristol task that could tower over both Singapore and France’s efforts.

“People gravitate towards interesting spaces, ” said Sarah Rodriguez, head of advertising at Edible Backyard City. “While many people visit to see the plants and to learn about metropolitan farming, there are also… visitors who choose the ambience or the view. ”

To deal with increasingly urgent foods security and sustainability concerns, innovators in debt Dot are taking agriculture to new heights. The city-state can be capitalising on the status quo as a regional advancement leader to bring farming into the future. Yet amidst high-tech tasks and cosmopolitan advancements, traditional farms danger being left behind.

As CapitaSpring welcomed its initial visitors, reports of export bans and disrupted food supply stores spread through Southeast Asia. Indonesia, the world’s top supplier of palm oil, released a three-week ban on exports from the product on 28 April in an attempt to stabilise cooking oil prices. A month later, Malaysian Prime Minister Ismail Yaakob announced the curb on poultry exports from one June, causing issue in neighbouring Singapore, which imports a third of its poultry through Malaysia.

From directly to left: a see from Edible Backyard City’s latest CapitaLand farm, a gardener tends to plants for the rooftop farm, edible herbs and plant life fill the beds within CapitaLand’s urban farm


Foods security is not a new issue for Singapore. Currently dependent on imports for more than 90% of its food, the government’s ‘30 by 30’ initiative seeks to produce 30% from the country’s nutrition locally by 2030. Yet recent bans upon exports and upended supply chains because of the Ukraine-Russia conflict possess added an increased sense of urgency.

“Recent activities have really demonstrated how vulnerable Singapore can be if there are disruptions to supply chains, ” said John Teng, adjunct older fellow in the H. Rajaratnam School of International Studies at Nanyang Technological University Singapore. “Not just in terms of the actual meals commodities themselves, but also in terms of peripherals [such as] rising fuel prices. ”

In the meantime, the public sector will be stepping in with brand new grants and possibilities for commercial farmers. These include the Agri-food Cluster Transformation (ACT) Fund, which provides assistance for farms taking a look at innovation and test-bedding and technology upscaling. The first Agri-Tech Career Conversion Programme was launched in early 2022, designed to train the nation’s workforce in abilities including Smart Farming and Internet associated with Things technology.

Some of the city-state’s urban farms have already embraced innovation. Ready-to-eat Garden City’s initial Singapore project, CapitaSpring’s sister farm along with the nearby Funan Mall hosts a good aquaponics pond exactly where nutrient-dense water from the resident fish is filtered and utilized to water the adjoining plants.

But behind the particular hype, Teng is definitely sceptical about the long lasting benefits of urban, high-tech farms.

“Even though there is a lot of talk about durability, the green strategy, and so on, many of our farming practices, especially great farming practices have yet to be verified sustainable, ” he said.  

Many traditional farmers lack not just the resources but additionally the mindset plus inclination to trendy using new, costly technologies. Meanwhile, because Singapore remains not even close to its 30 simply by 30 goals, innovators in alternative healthy proteins and lab-grown meat are hungrily trying to capitalise on the terms, which, since Teng notes, refer to general nutrition, not just organic foodstuffs.


From right to remaining: a plot associated with exotic and ready-to-eat plants at Bollywood Farms welcomes visitors to ‘Wild Singapore, ’ the Asian Veggie Garden at Bollywood Farms, the entry to Bollywood Farm’s Poison Ivy diner, which serves dishes made from local create

Within the opposite side of the diminutive island, around 33 kilometres (20 miles) from CapitaSpring’s manicured soil bedrooms, greenery sprawls across a 10-acre (4-hectare) estate. The property is divided in to 12 plots, hosting Malaysian pomelo, Bangladeshi bananas and local Singaporean kangkong and grass-green plus lemon-yellow signposts tagging “ASEAN “compost” or “Wild Singapore. ” Near the entrance, a good open-air bistro called Poison Ivy acts dishes made with the particular farm’s produce.

“You can eat all vegetation, ” said the farm’s co-founder plus landowner, Ivy Singh-Lim. “Some you can just eat once. ”

Bollywood Farms’ co-founder, “gentle warrior, ” Ivy Singh-Lim

Bollywood Farms was founded within 2000 by Lim Ho Seng, previous CEO of a Singaporean retail behemoth, great wife, landowner and former business advancement leader Singh-Lim. The particular couple’s retirement project was launched to create a lasting ecosystem of foods produce.

For the landed couple, agriculture may be an easily affordable expense, but the reality for most agricultural workers is usually markedly different. The average farmer’s wage within Singapore is SGD 2, 444 ($1, 772), a little more compared to half the country’s average monthly revenue of SGD four, 680 ($3, 394).

“Farmers need to be incentivised, ” Teng said.  

When Singapore became a completely independent nation in 1965, farming was flourishing. Vegetable production filled 50% of nearby demand. Pork had been produced at a little surplus for foreign trade. Low labour costs boosted overall results and the sector was a valuable contributor to the national economy.

But a report released shortly after independence revealed the stresses beneath the success. Almost all farms were little, family-based operations in which the owners had less than four years of education and lacked the main city and resources to upscale or stay profitable.  

Concerns emerged over the pollution and environmental damage brought on by pig farming. By the 1970s the government got turned its focus on modernising the labor force and agricultural industry through technology.

“The govt made a very mindful policy effort to downplay the part of agriculture and restrict the… quantity of land [and] human resources to diversify the economy in the 1980’s, ” Teng said. While urbanisation boosted the particular national GDP, farming professionals faced issues.

About 1% of Singapore’s 720 square kms (278 square miles) is dedicated towards agriculture and conventional farms are only allowed to be built in accepted designated areas. Maqui berry farmers apply for land tender and a licence in the Singapore Food Agency, the statutory board responsible for managing urban agriculture. Subsequent approvals from various other govt entities are also needed, including the Urban Redevelopment Authority, the Property Transport Authority as well as the National Environment Company.

“The government is not offering you land free of charge and smallholder farmers can not really afford in order to borrow, ” Teng noted.

Rodriguez noted gas and food price inflation highlight the particular brokenness of Singapore’s food system exactly where imported produce, frequently grown with chemical intervention, is more available than organic, grown locally food. “The solution is a self-sustaining nearby food system, decentralised, run and possessed by the community, ” she said.


The view of Singapore’s cityscape from CapitaLand urban farm

Singh-Lim finds the existing siloed structure as well as the lack of expertise in the public sector irritating and a barrier to farmers supporting their particular businesses through ancillary income, such as restaurants.

“It took me one year in order to quarrel with the bastards in the agriculture division [to build my farm], ” she recalled.

When Bollywood Farms was founded, management fell underneath the purview of the Agri-Food and Veterinary Specialist, a statutory board that was disbanded within 2019 and its responsibilities split. A 2004 decision to incorporate a restaurant required another licence application under a new government table.

“When I applied for change of use, it threw a whole spanner within the works… they nearly fainted, ” the lady said wryly. “In the UK, they knew that small farming was not profitable, therefore that’s why they incorporated Bed & Breakfasts. They knew what was growing has been leisure. ”

High-tech urban farms are exempt from the land limitations. Many of those operations, including Edible Garden City’s Funan and CapitaSpring entities, are straight linked with upmarket dining places serving their produce and helping increase awareness of farm-to-table eating amongst discerning Singaporean diners.

“Working with skilled culinary teams is important for farmers to reach out to even more individuals, ” Rodriguez mentioned. “The way to the particular hearts of Singaporeans is through our stomachs. ”

Singh-Lim feels that farming should be accessible and noticeable, not just on Singaporeans’ plates but also within their everyday lives. High-rise rooftop farms ought to be reserved for particular solar and water-collection projects. Communal allotments and aquaculture ponds could be incorporated around each of the 1 . 2009 million public housing units built from the Housing Development Plank.

“We should convert every piece of land into an eco friendly, useful, productive backyard, ” she mentioned. “People say that we now have no land. We have plenty of land. Yet think about this: 1% of land is for agriculture, 15% is for the particular military. ”

The future of farming relies on a balance between your agri-tech and traditional methods. Innovation will there be to bolster understanding of natural sustainable gardening practices, according to Rodriguez.

“We need to strengthen the entire ecosystem of farming in Singapore, through training and growth to partnerships and awareness, ” the lady said.

Teng said several countries face a policy dilemma of whether or not to support small farms or more productive, great operations: “Singapore is extremely focused on productivity plus efficiency, but our own country will be poorer off if we do not have a countryside with small, conventional farms, ” he stated.  

For Singh-Lim, the logic and the alternative are simple: Singapore’s farming methods may be divided but their ultimate goal is the same.

“Grow nearby. Eat local. Consume less. Waste less, ” she said.

Photos by Amanda Oon for Southeast Asia Globe