Narendra Modi’s hope for a thaw amid uncertain geopolitics between India and China

Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently addressed India’s connection with its long-standing adversary, China. He claimed that sanity had resurfaced near the disputed border between India and China and that relations should be strengthened.

These are striking comments, because tensions have been high since a nasty border clash in the northern Ladakh region in 2020 – the deadliest since a 1962 war.

Mao Ning, a spokesperson for the Chinese government, applauded Modi’s statement and said” the two countries should be companions that contribute to each other’s victory.”

Given recent improvements in diplomatic ties, Modi’s proposal for a closer relationship isn’t exactly as significant as it may seem. However, the relationship is still strained, and much needs to be fixed- both symmetrically and more widely geopolitically- for it to achieve true rapprochement.

There are many positive aspects to India-China relationships.

China has been India’s leading trading partner since the Ladakh clash, and bilateral trade has continued to be strong. They collaborate multilaterally with the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank and Brics, the empire of significant developing nations. They have a common goal of advancing non-Western economic theories, preventing Islamist terrorism, and rejecting what they see as US social campaigning.

Even after the Ladakh clash sunk ties to their lowest level in decades, the two militaries continued to hold high-level dialogues, which resulted in a deal in October to resume border patrols. Modi met Chinese President Xi Jinping at a Brics summit in Russia that month and they pledged further co-operation. In January, the two sides agreed to resume direct flights.

The connection is also strained, though.

India and China both have enmity with the other’s primary rival, Pakistan, and each side has a strong safety ally.

In the contested Kashmir region, China opposes American plans. By preventing India from becoming a member of powerful organizations like the Nuclear Suppliers Group and becoming a permanent member of the UN Security Council, Beijing stifles India’s tremendous power interests.

China’s largest naval base is located in India’s wider maritime backyard, and it is the only martial base it has elsewhere.

Delhi absolutely rejects the Belt and Road Initiative, the communication corridor through which Beijing has expanded its footprints in India’s neighborhood, for passing through India-claimed place.

In the meantime, India is tying more knots with Taiwan, which China views as a rebel state. The Dalai Lama, the Tibetan president who is now in exile, is a guest there. He is regarded as a harmful dissident by Beijing.

India is negotiating the sale of hypersonic missiles to Southeast Asian nations to deter Chinese threats in the South China Sea. China makes an effort to combat it by participating in some international communities, including the Indo-Pacific Quad and the Middle East Europe Economic Corridor.

Watch out for a few signs to get a better feel of the relationship’s potential direction.

Borders deals are one. The 2,100-mile ( 3,380km)-long frontier, which is equal to the size of Greece, has a population of 50 thousand square miles, but it is still disputed.

The relationship’s biggest predictor is the frontier situation. Trust was shattered by the Ladakh conflict, and a new prowling agreement from last year helped to restore it. This would be good for ties if the two parties could develop more measures to encourage confidence.

Potential high-level discussion is also crucial. If Modi and Xi meet this year, which both place a prime on specific politics, this may increase the pace of diplomatic ties recently. They will have opportunities to attend conferences for leaders in July, the G20 in November, and the Shanghai Co-operation Group (SCO ) sometime later this year.

Chinese investment would provide crucial capital to key Indian industries, from manufacturing to renewable energy, and help India’s$ 85 billion ( £65.77 billion ) trade deficit with China.

An increase in these investments may give India a boost in terms of economic growth and give China more access to the nation’s largest, fastest-growing business. Greater industrial cooperation would give more motivation to lower broader conflicts.

Watch out for regional and global advances.

Bangladesh, the Island, Nepal, and Sri Lanka are four of India’s neighbors, and their new leaders are more pro-China than their successors. However, they have so far attempted to strike a balance between Beijing and Delhi and avoid China.

Delhi’s worries about Beijing’s effect in India’s neighborhood might get a little lessen if this persists. Also, if China were to withdraw from its growing collaboration with India’s near friend Russia, which would be more likely if the conflict in Ukraine, which would have increased Moscow’s dependence on Beijing, were to stop, this might boost India-China ties.

The Trump element also has a significant impact.

Despite imposing tariffs on China, US President Donald Trump has indicated that he wants to alleviate relations with Beijing.

India would want to make sure its personal relations to China are in a better position if he does and Delhi worries that Washington may not be as committed to supporting India as it is in helping to counter China.

Furthermore, given the 10 % regular tariff differences between the US and India, it could be that Trump’s looming mutual tariff policy will hit India hard, which would give it another incentive to boost commercial cooperation with Beijing.

Both China and India are Asia’s two largest nations, and both see themselves as glad civilisations.

They are all-natural rivals. However, new positive developments in ties, in addition to the possibility for diplomatic progress on various fronts, could strengthen the relationship and make Modi’s conciliatory language more than rhetoric.

Follow BBC News India on Instagram, YouTube, Twitter and Facebook.