COP28: Tuvalu negotiator flies 8,000 miles to save home

Mervina Paueli

The UN climate talks start haggling over how protect the oceans on Saturday – and one woman will be closely watching.

Mervina Paueli, 25, has come to Dubai to negotiate a future for her home, Tuvalu – a group of low-lying Pacific islands.

We owe the oceans a lot – by absorbing heat, they protect us from the full cost of global warming.

If this summit agrees to slash fossil fuel use, oceans could be a big winner.

This is Mervina’s first COP summit – she was in the air for 24 hours, flying from Fiji to Hong Kong before finally landing here in the United Arab Emirates.

“We all have that umbilical cord attachment to our lands. Anything for my country is worth it,” she says.

Around 11,000 people live on Tuvalu's nine islands

Getty Images

As a negotiator with Tuvalu’s team, she belongs to a club no-one wants to join – a community facing a wipe-out of home and history.

“The numbers are not looking good for Tuvalu. Picturing it just not being there anymore makes me feel really sad,” she says.

She talks about the island’s white sands and beautiful clear waters lying either side of her family home.

Sea levels are 0.15 metres higher than 30 years ago, with an average increase rate of 5mm a year. That increase is expected to speed up and by 2050 the sea will be be 20cm higher than it is today.

The islanders’ culture, history and livelihood is totally reliant on the seas. They need healthy oceans with good fish stocks, and crucially, limited or no rise in sea levels.

That relationship is not unique to this population of a few thousand.

The oceans have provided a “great service” to Earth and everything that lives on it, says Ko Barrett, senior climate advisor at the US’s National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) and vice chair of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC).

Their dark waters have absorbed 90% of the warming humans have created by burning coal, oil and gas and releasing greenhouse gases into the atmosphere.

But that service could soon end. Oceans are showing signs of huge stress from climate change, pollution and loss of habitats.

Metres away from the politicians at COP28, the waters shimmering off the shores of Dubai are close to 30C. In July, the average global ocean temperature reached its highest on record.

The UN says Tuvalu is extremely vulnerable to climate change

Getty Images

In Tuvalu, tuna are relocating to cooler waters, pushing fishermen further and further away from the shores, Mervina explains.

Despite this, oceans are the “poor cousin” of climate talks, the UN Special Envoy on Oceans Peter Thompson says, speaking at the Oceans Pavilion at COP28.

The first time oceans were mentioned in a UN climate talks deal was just two years ago, he explains.

On Saturday ministers from major ocean nations – including the US, Norway, and the Seychelles – meet to discuss next steps and how they can provide climate solutions including renewable power from tidal energy.

More than 100 organisations have signed the Dubai Oceans Declaration – including scientists anchored on a ship off the coast of Peru, frantically working to understand how long oceans have left before they start pumping out heat.

Collette Kelly from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution is on board, hanging instruments from the ship’s side to measure nitrogen levels and acidification, both signs of higher ocean temperatures in the waters deep below.

The Dubai Oceans Declaration calls for investment in ocean science, so experts can better understand issues like rising sea levels and the death of coral reefs.

“Put simply, the ocean is one of the best solutions we have to tackle climate change. Governments must commit to ocean-based action in their national climate goals, strategies and policies,” says Tom Pickerell, director of the ocean programme at the World Resources Institute.

But it may be too late for Pacific Islanders. Sea level rise has been baked into Earth’s system by melting glaciers, and it is uncertain whether sea surface temperatures will stabilise at cooler levels.

Recognising the existential threat facing these communities, in November close neighbour Australia offered climate refugee visas to Pacific Islanders.

Mervina says she would not take up the offer. “No. I just love Tuvalu. I would lose my culture and community where everybody knows each other, everybody helps each other,” she explains.

She describes a New Year’s eve party on her grandmother’s island.

“We were children but we stayed up until four o’clock in the morning. Everyone was dancing the traditional fakaseasea – the kids beating tin cans. Whenever you hear it, you join it. Whoever wants to join starts dancing,” she says.

She plans to stay and fight for this community and tell COP28 it must save her island home.

Related Topics

Continue Reading

Kaathal: When Malayalam superstar Mammootty plays a gay character

Mammootty and Jyothika in KaathalMammootty Kampany

Three weeks ago, the teaser for Kaathal: The Core, a Malayalam-language film starring Indian actor Mammootty, dropped on YouTube.

It revealed little about the film’s main conflict but sparked discussions in the southern state of Kerala, the film’s home state. A superstar portraying a gay character became the buzz among fans, critics, and commentators.

No Indian star with a legacy spanning half a century and three National Film Awards, and a massive fan following, had taken on such a role.

Directed by Jeo Baby, known for the 2021 hit The Great Indian Kitchen addressing patriarchy, Kaathal quickly ignited conversations among his fans and followers.

The film tells the story of a closeted gay man in a heterosexual marriage. As Mathew (played by Mammootty) prepares to contest a local election, his wife Omana (played by Jyothika) files for divorce, alleging her husband is gay. The film explores the ripple effects the case has in their family and community.

“I wanted to make this film about living together with the LGBTQ community and how this works within our families,” Baby told the BBC.

The film demanded the performance of a talented actor like Mammootty, who also produced it, he says. “He understood the film immediately and was willing to do it.”

The reviews have been overwhelmingly positive, and shows sold out throughout Kerala.

Mammootty, Jyothika and RS Panickar in a scene from the film

Mammootty Kampany

But social media posts of Kaathal’s posters and trailer, including those shared on Mammootty’s accounts, also invited comments by anti-LGBT groups asking people to boycott the film and criticising the actor for his role. Muslim clerics criticised its representation of homosexuality, saying it would “brainwash the youth”.

Such a backlash would not be unexpected for the makers and for Mammootty, says Athul PV, an organiser of the Kerala Queer Pride.

“He’s an actor that people admire a lot, so when he plays this character it makes you think how much thought he put into picking this role and making the film,” Athul says.

Many in the state’s LGBTQ community embraced the film’s “sensitive” portrayal of a married gay man’s experience.

“The film is not above criticism but it’s a daring attempt,” says Prijith PK, founder of Queerythm, a community-based organisation.

Despite being a state with high development indicators and the highest literacy rate in India, Kerala still remains patriarchal and conservative in many areas.

Actor Dileep with Gopika in Chanthupottu

Lal Jose

The state is well-known for its vibrant film industry and hosts an annual film festival that attracts worldwide audiences.

However, Roshni Prabhakaran, an academic who has worked on gender representations in films, notes a scarcity of “sensitive films depicting the LGBTQ community”.

Although Malayalam cinema has had queer-coded characters from the 1970s, one of the first mainstream portrayals was in the 2005 film Chanthupottu.

The film depicts the story of an effeminate man who eventually adopts more masculine traits. It faced sharp criticism from activists and members of Kerala’s LGBTQ community for spreading dangerous misconceptions, even as its filmmaker denied that the character was gay. Activists said the film’s title was a term often used to insult transgender persons – chanthupottu literally means a red bindi, a bright dot applied in the centre of the forehead.

“Chanthupottu’s impact was entirely negative,” says Athul. “It left behind the idea that this is what queer people are like.”

In recent years, well-known Kerala film stars have played gay characters on screen.

Nivin Pauly’s 2019 film Moothon garnered attention at film festivals but struggled to connect with the broader audience, says Prof Prabhakaran. On the other hand, Prithviraj Sukumaran’s 2013 film Mumbai Police, despite its mainstream appeal with a star lead, faced criticism for its “problematic representation, with a focus on shame and homophobia”.

Sudhi Kozhikode seen driving a car in the film

Mammootty Kampany

In that sense, Kaathal is entirely different, say many. “We’ve not seen this difficult phase – of a closeted man coming out of a heterosexual marriage – in Malayalam cinema,” says Prof Prabhakaran.

Gay men who’ve watched Kaathal say it’s clear the film was made with the involvement of the community.

The film is not “queerphobic” in the way most mainstream films with the LGBTQ community representation are, says Prijith, who works as a diversity and inclusion manager at the Kerala Knowledge Economy Mission.

“Kaathal is almost like an apology for the history of queer indignity and misrepresentation in Malayalam films.”

Mammootty’s commanding presence influences both the film and its reception. Despite the actor’s reputation for infusing his characters with gravitas and depth, his filmography also has its fair share of regressive ideas and misogyny.

In 2016, the actor was pulled up by the state’s women’s commission for his film Kasaba and its dialogues that “insulted women”. The commission said the delivery of “sub-standard dialogues” by an actor like Mammootty could lead to a “dangerous acceptance” of such behaviour by the public.

“With Kaathal, it’s almost like he’s himself undoing the hyper-masculine, powerful, arrogant on-screen persona we’ve seen in his films so far,” Prijith says.

Activists and supporters of LGBTQ community walk a pride parade in Chennai on June 26, 2022

Getty Images

In recent years, Mammootty has been looking to shore up his legacy by producing films under his banner and experimenting with ideas outside the limits of commercial success.

“Every new film [in Malayalam] is an experiment driven by the interests of the audience in new actors, new subjects and new films,” he said in a recent interview.

“I think this is the main reason why the Indian film industry looks to Malayalam cinema. Naturally, I also want my films to be a part of this journey.”

Kaathal tells the story of “many men in our society,” Prijith says.

“The film shows these are people in our own homes.”

BBC News India is now on YouTube. Click here to subscribe and watch our documentaries, explainers and features.

Presentational grey line

Read more India stories from the BBC:

Presentational grey line

Related Topics

Continue Reading

Marapi eruption: Hikers recount escape from 'Mountain of Fire'

Mount Marapi spews scalding volcanic ash and rocks into the air on 3 December, killing 23 peopleReuters

“Initially, only smoke emerged, then it started raining rocks, followed by ash. There was no warning,” says hiker Irvanda Mulya.

Mr Irvanda and 17 of his friends had planned to climb Mount Marapi for more than a month. But what started out as a fun expedition up one of Indonesia’s most active volcanoes took a deadly turn last weekend.

Marapi, which translates from the local Minang language to “Mountain of Fire”, spewed scalding hot ash and rocks into the air on Sunday, leaving 23 people dead due to severe burns, including 12 from the group.

Mr Irvanda survived with extensive injuries along with his friend, Muhammad Fadli. They told the BBC how the eruption unfolded on the slopes of the mountain.

The group of friends, most of whom met in school, decided to hike Marapi “just to have fun”. While most of them were avid mountaineers, seven of them were climbing a mountain for the first time. Marapi seemed like a sensible option as they live in Padang, a city three hours away, which is close by local standards.

Marapi stands at 2,891m (9,485 ft) in West Sumatra province. It is one of Indonesia’s 127 volcanoes. The country is located on the Pacific “Ring of Fire”, where the meeting of continental plates causes high volcanic and seismic activity.

‘There was no warning’

The group arrived at Marapi’s base camp last Friday and started their push to the summit early the next day. They spent Saturday night in tents set up around a small white monument called Tugu Abel, about 600m from the peak. It was named after a man who died when Marapi erupted in 1996.

It rained heavily when the group reached the peak on Saturday, Mr Irvanda said. But the poor weather that continued throughout the night did not douse their enthusiasm. They were greeted with amazing views at sunrise on Sunday and some considered staying through sunset.

Eventually, they decided to start their descent early. Mr Fadli, Mr Irvanda and two others went ahead at about 15:00 local time (0800 GMT).

All of a sudden, the ground started to shake.

“I covered my mouth to avoid inhaling ash. I ran downhill, tumbled for a bit, saw [my friend] Bima already below, helped him briefly, and then both of us continued descending,” Mr Irvanda said.

Muhammad Fadli in hospital

Mr Fadli broke his finger trying to dodge stones falling from the sky with his hands. One rock hit his leg, causing a fracture.

“I forced myself to walk. I used my heels to continue down the path… We kept trying to move downhill by constantly looking for places to protect ourselves on the cliffs,” he said.

The group slowly made their way down the mountain in treacherous conditions and with multiple injuries, trying to avoid a cloud of heat, and occasionally taking cover behind large rocks. They were driven not only by desperation to survive, but also a sense of responsibility for each other’s safety.

“We were the only hope. We were the only team already going down. So that we can call the search and rescue team to evacuate people who are still at the top,” Mr Fadli said.

A fifth hiker, who caught up with the four leaders, managed to contact the National Search and Rescue Agency, which instructed them to wait at a fork in the road where they could be picked up. The five then continued to climb down, and managed to help two other female hikers along the way.

It would be five hours before rescuers arrived. The group had gone without food, but Mr Fadli said he did not feel hungry. “Because I had ashes inside my mouth too,” he said.

‘Run, Marapi is erupting’

Another hiker, Muhammad Iqbal, descended from Marapi with a different group and reached the foot of the volcano just before it erupted. He said he was surprised to hear a troop of monkeys screaming frantically.

“[They sounded] excited, like they were calling the king or something. They were roaring,” he said.

And then, a farmer ran past him, screaming, “Run, boy, run, Mount Marapi has erupted.”

“At first, we thought she was kidding. We didn’t hear any eruption,” Mr Iqbal said.

“But when we reached the [end] point, people were gathering and we saw some of them running. Someone was speeding off with their motorbike,” he said.

When he finally came to terms with what had just happened, Mr Iqbal was shocked.

“My mind went blank. I was playing near the crater of Mount Marapi just hours ago,” he said, adding he felt lucky to have gone down before the eruption.

Officials said most of the 75 hikers in Marapi during the eruption were evacuated and received treatment for burns. Twelve injured victims were undergoing treatment in hospital, as of Wednesday.

Rescuers help with the evacuation while others watch on

Getty Images

In the days that followed, Mr Iqbal began to question why there were no warning signs – save for the screaming monkeys – or clear instructions to stay away from dangerous spots.

Marapi has stayed on the second-highest alert level of Indonesia’s four-step warning scale since 2011. People are not allowed within a 3km radius from the peak – but this was not made clear to the hikers that the BBC spoke to.

“Why were we still allowed to climb Marapi, even to the crater, like I did?” said Mr Iqbal, who was attempting the hike for the first time.

Experts told the BBC the death toll could have been minimised if hikers were prohibited from lingering so close to the crater.

Dian Indriati, who leads the West Sumatra Natural Resources Conservation Agency, said officials had installed a sign saying that the area was “extremely dangerous”, but hikers appeared to have ignored it.

Eko Teguh Paripurna, a disaster management specialist from UPN Veteran Yogyakarta, said authorities approved hiking permits with inadequate requirements, while climbers appeared to have underestimated the dangers ahead.

Mr Fadli and Mr Irvanda said they would not climb mountains for a while.

“I am grateful for being given a chance at life by God… But many of my friends lost their lives. This trauma runs deep.

“This is what bothers me so much in my sleep, because I failed to save all of my friends,” Mr Irvanda said.

Nicky Widadio and Halbert Chaniago from the BBC World Service contributed to this report.

Continue Reading

How menopause changes the brain and 3 things women should know to protect against dementia

THREE STEPS TO PROTECT YOUR BRAIN

Several studies have found that up to 40 per cent of dementia cases could be prevented, said Dr Jessica Caldwell, director of the Women’s Alzheimer’s Movement Prevention Center at the Cleveland Clinic in Las Vegas. And a few lifestyle changes in midlife, including quitting smoking, reducing alcohol intake, sleeping better and remaining mentally and socially active, aid in prevention.

But for women in menopause, experts say that three things in particular are likely to have the most impact by addressing both the short-term symptoms as well as the long-term risk of dementia.

1. Hormone therapy, timed right

For decades, researchers were concerned that the hormone therapy used to treat menopause symptoms was associated with an increased risk of developing dementia in older women. But recent studies, including one published in October that reviewed the findings of over 50 studies, look more closely at the timing of the therapy and suggest a more nuanced picture: Hormone therapy that was started around the time when menopausal symptoms began was associated with a reduced risk of Alzheimer’s disease and dementia.

Other studies have found that hormone therapy had no effect on dementia and Alzheimer’s risk, Dr Maki said, but these treatments are effective at addressing hot flashes and night sweats as well as improving quality of life, all of which are “important determinants of brain health,” she said.

2. Consistent exercise

Physical inactivity presents a greater risk for neurodegenerative diseases in women than in men, Dr Caldwell said. “We know that physical inactivity is a risk factor for dementia. And women throughout their lives, on average, are twice as likely to be physically inactive than men,” she said.

A 2018 study that followed almost 200 middle-aged women for 44 years found that the greater their fitness level at the start of the study, the lower their risk of developing dementia later in life. And Dr Mosconi found that brain scans of physically active middle-aged women had fewer Alzheimer’s biomarkers compared to their sedentary counterparts.

Continue Reading

Going on your first cruise? Here's what passengers should know to ensure smooth sailing

2. BRING A CARRY-ON

After you check your bag at the terminal, it may take several hours before it’s delivered to your stateroom. “Be sure to pack a carry-on with all of the essentials you might need during that window of time,” said Colleen McDaniel, editor-in-chief of cruise news site Cruise Critic, who suggested including “medication, sunscreen, a bathing suit, a phone charger and other essentials that you’ll need as soon as you board.”

3. SIGN UP FOR ACTIVITIES IN ADVANCE

Popular onboard restaurants, shore excursions and spa treatments can fill up quickly so book ahead. Many companies will let you book in advance through their website or app, but if not, head to excursion and activity desks soon after you’ve boarded.

“The theatre productions are incredible and produced at a very high quality,” said Chris Thompson, an avid cruiser of 35 years based in London. “You can usually reserve a seat in advance for free, but if it’s booked up, try showing up 15 minutes before the start of the show when seats often become available.”

Thompson also suggested going to a specialty restaurant on the first night when there is likely to be more availability. “Most people eat in the main dining room while they settle in, so chances are you’ll find a nice table at one of the special restaurants,” he said.

Continue Reading

CNA Explains: 2023 is the hottest year ever. How will tropical Singapore cope with record temperatures?

What does the heat do to our minds and bodies?

Studies show a correlation between hot days and an increase in hospital visits for mood and anxiety disorders.

On a physical level, heat extremes have an impact on the human body, which has an average temperature of about 36.5 degrees Celsius. Anything beyond that, and we start sweating to help the body stay cool.

If that water loss is not replenished, we get dehydrated and our organs start to struggle with their essential tasks.

The heart is forced to pump harder as it tries to regulate the body’s temperature.

Blood vessels thin as more blood is brought to the skin to aid in the sweating process, but this lowers blood pressure, leading to the risk of a heart attack.

Dehydration also decreases oxygen supply to the kidney, responsible for removing extra waste and extra fluid from the body. This can lead to chronic kidney disease.

Prolonged exposure to intense heat can also escalate to heat stroke, which is marked by an elevated body temperature, a rapid strong pulse and the loss of consciousness.

This can be fatal if the victim is not taken to a medical facility quickly.

Continue Reading

Commentary: Amid ever-rising premiums, let’s make it easier for no-claim individuals to switch private health insurers

PORTABILITY FOR NO-CLAIM INDIVIDUALS

What can be done?

Part of the answer, as always, is government supervision and action.

In fact, the insurance business is regulated and there are rules governing what they can do and to make sure they are financially sustainable.

Recently, the authorities named the four largest insurers here – AIA Singapore, Income Insurance, Prudential Assurance and Great Eastern Life – as companies that are too big to fail and would hence be subjected to more rigorous standards of supervision.

Like large banks, these insurers present a systemic risk to the economy if any of them were to collapse.

This is a good move that should help ensure these companies are sound and financially secure, now that big brother is watching them more closely.

The safeguards are mainly to protect the health of these companies, but who is there to look after the interests of customers?

Caveat emptor or let the buyer beware?

This cannot be applied to health insurance for one important reason: MediSave funds are allowed to be used to pay for premiums of MediShield Life and Integrated Shield Plans.  

As these are Government-mandated funds, the authorities have a responsibility to make sure they are used in a way that protects the public interest.

It means closer oversight of the premiums charged and what they cover.

The inability of customers to switch their plans to another company is a major issue. It penalises those stuck in companies that are not efficient or competitive leaving them with no recourse even if they are fit and healthy and have never made any claims.

What would happen if switching is allowed without losing coverage of pre-existing conditions?

This would be a godsend for customers but might be too much of a bitter pill for companies to swallow if they are suddenly deluged with high-risk cases.

It would be unfair to expect these companies to accept them without raising their premiums.

A better solution would be to allow portability for those who have not made any claims for a certain number of years.

This will lessen the risk for companies and encourage more people to stay healthy.

It is a more realistic and workable approach than the suggestion that has often been made to charge lower premiums for people who have not made any claims, as in the case of motor vehicle insurance.

The problem with this idea is that it will result in much higher premiums for those with medical problems.

Someone has to pay for the shortfall if premiums are lowered for the healthy and the burden will fall increasingly on the sick.

It is not right to inflict this penalty on people requiring medical treatment and those who suggest this should be careful what they wish for – you never know when you might require costly treatment.

Continue Reading

Are BPA-free plastic bottles really safe? Here’s what you need to know

Tritan shares similar characteristics with polycarbonate, such as clarity, durability and resistance to impact, said Liew. But it is BPA-free; and it costs more.

While some Tritan bottles are labelled as such, Nalgene bottles carry only the “BPA-free” label, Liew added. “Consumers should be aware of what they’re buying and also do their own due diligence.”

In a consumer advisory shared with Talking Point, the SFA said consumers should use reusable bottles or food containers according to instructions. For example, only containers labelled microwave-safe should be used for reheating food in the microwave.

A product should be replaced when its integrity has been compromised, such as when it is cloudy, discoloured or cracked.

When choosing reusable products, consumers can also opt for other materials, such as glass, porcelain or stainless steel, especially for hot foods and liquids.

Watch this episode of Talking Point here. The programme airs on Channel 5 every Thursday at 9.30pm.

Continue Reading

BPA-free, food-grade or Tritan: How safe are your plastic bottles?

Tritan shares similar characteristics with polycarbonate, such as clarity, durability and resistance to impact, said Liew. But it is BPA-free; and it costs more.

While some Tritan bottles are labelled as such, Nalgene bottles carry only the “BPA-free” label, Liew added. “Consumers should be aware of what they’re buying and also do their own due diligence.”

In a consumer advisory shared with Talking Point, the SFA said consumers should use reusable bottles or food containers according to instructions. For example, only containers labelled microwave-safe should be used for reheating food in the microwave.

A product should be replaced when its integrity has been compromised, such as when it is cloudy, discoloured or cracked.

When choosing reusable products, consumers can also opt for other materials, such as glass, porcelain or stainless steel, especially for hot foods and liquids.

Watch this episode of Talking Point here. The programme airs on Channel 5 every Thursday at 9.30pm.

Continue Reading