China has recruited retired British fighter pilots to train its People’s Liberation Army (PLA) pilots, giving Beijing’s rapidly modernizing air force deep insights into Western air combat tactics, techniques and procedures.
Britain’s Defense Ministry has acknowledged that China had recruited as many as 30 former Royal Air Force (RAF) fighter pilots to train their Chinese counterparts using Chinese planes, paying them as much as US$270,000 per year, according to a New York Times report citing anonymous sources.
While none of the retired pilots have flown the F-35, the Royal Air Force’s (RAF) most advanced warplane, they have flown advanced aircraft such as the Eurofighter Typhoon, Jaguar and Tornado, the report said.
China has also attempted to recruit pilots trained on the highly-classified F-35, but its recruitment efforts have apparently not succeeded, Sky News reported this week.
The New York Times report notes that China recruited former British pilots through a private flying test company based in South Africa. The same report also notes that other allied nations’ fighter pilots have received similar offers from China.
Apart from British pilots, China has reportedly made similar offers to Australian pilots, as reported by 9News this week. In response, Australian Defense Minister Richard Marles has ordered the Australian Ministry of Defense (MOD) to investigate such reports and provide clear guidance on how to deal with the matter.
The former fighter pilots, some in their late 50s, can pass on decades of experience to China’s new pilots, which is in line with China’s efforts to improve its fighter pilot training program and modernize its air force to match Western standards.
These skills could be pivotal in a Taiwan conflict, where Taipei’s US-trained and equipped air force will be the self-governing island’s first line of defense against a Chinese blockade or invasion. China’s Western-trained fighter pilots could use the same techniques against the US and its allies if and when they attempt to come to Taiwan’s aid.
The UK is taking the threat seriously enough to issue a rare intelligence alert warning its former fighter pilots against working for the Chinese military, the BBC reported this week.
Currently, the UK government has no laws or policies on the books to stop its former fighter pilots from accepting contracts to work with the Chinese military. That could soon change with reports the UK plans to introduce new laws that criminalize ex-military personnel from taking contracts to train members of specific militaries, likely to include China.
UK Minister of State for the Armed Forces and Veterans James Heappey said that the British government plans to introduce a “two-strike rule” to warn former RAF pilots against dealing with China before they face potential prosecution, The Guardian reported this week.
“We’ve approached the people involved and have been clear to them that it’s our expectation they would not continue to be part of that organization. We are going to put into law that once people have been given that warning it will become an offense to go forward and continue with that training,” said Heappey, according to the report.
China has denied the covert recruitment efforts, with Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Wang Weibin saying he was unaware of such practices, The Washington Post reported this week.
In a Forbes article this week, Paul Kennard notes that although these former British fighter pilots may not be knowledgeable about the most up-to-date weapons systems, they still think in the same way as NATO pilots now on active duty.
Specifically, Kennard said that the ex-pilots will still approach mission planning like their active-duty counterparts, including through the so-called Composite Air Operation (COMAO) framework where small numbers of high-value air assets can be effective over multiple individual sub-missions with some used in diversionary tactics.
Such complex missions require intensive training and regular practice, which China seeks to glean from the former British fighter pilots.
Kennan also notes that China’s efforts to recruit retired British and other allied fighter pilots are part of a “normalize deviance” strategy to gain information on top-tier Western platforms, such as the F-35, including regarding the aircraft’s strengths and weaknesses.
He writes that China has sought to convince active-duty British and allied military personnel that taking a contract from China is no different than taking one from Saudi Arabia, widely seen as allied with the US and West. Poor economic and career prospects after military service are clear motivators for former military pilots to take China’s rich offers, Kennan says.
Kennan notes that Covid-19 has drastically slashed international travel, causing many former military pilots who flew commercial planes to suddenly lose their jobs. Moreover, he notes, older pilots are considered uneconomical to train on new aircraft, resulting in bleak prospects in the commercial aviation industry.
From China’s perspective, former British and allied fighter pilots provide the human element lacking in China’s current fighter training program.
Asia Times previously reported that China has recently accelerated its fighter pilot training program to fly fourth-generation fighters from four to six years down to three. However, China’s fighter training scenarios are highly scripted and tied to ground control, making them less responsive and adaptable to rapidly-changing combat conditions.
Although China has given its pilots the responsibility to make their flight plans and complete autonomy over their sorties, it will take time and expertise to reform the rigid practices institutionalized in its air force.
Former UK fighter pilots with specialized knowledge could thus provide the human unpredictability that China’s current fighter pilot training programs lack.