Woman with schizophrenia acquitted of murdering her 8-year-old daughter on grounds of unsound mind

Woman with schizophrenia acquitted of murdering her 8-year-old daughter on grounds of unsound mind

SINGAPORE: A lady suffering from untreated schizophrenia listened to voices telling her that the girl eight-year-old daughter has been an evil spirit and needed to be killed.

She stabbed her daughter in order to death in front of her younger daughter, who had been four at the time. The girl, who is now thirty six, cannot be named due to a gag order safeguarding the victim’s identification.

She pleaded guilty on Wednesday (Sep 20) to one count of killing , but  was acquitted of the charge under Section 251 of the Criminal Treatment Code as the lady was of unsound mind at the time of the offence.

The judge ordered that she be held in safe guardianship in prison and for the case to be documented to the minister. Based on Section 252 from the Criminal Procedure Program code, the minister will then order her to be confined in a psychiatric institution, prison yet another suitable place of secure custody during the President’s pleasure.

The particular court heard how the Singaporean woman created a relationship using a man in 2007, and they had 2 daughters. They did not get married.

Around 2014, the woman’s boyfriend returned to Cina to continue working presently there, while the woman stayed in Singapore with her daughters.

Before travel restrictions were imposed within China and Singapore because of the COVID-19 outbreak, either the woman or her boyfriend would certainly travel to visit each other. However , when the pandemic broke out, they would only video-call one another.

In 2020, the woman and the girl daughters moved to experience their family members inside an unit in Geylang.


Their loved ones noticed that the woman behaved strangely between 2018 and August 2020. For instance, she suspected her phone plus laptop were hacked, and that people were subsequent her.

The lady was often dubious that others would certainly harm her, and would throw away food and drinks that her family members prepared, preventing her children from consuming them too.

She also monitored her family members’ cooking to make sure no poison was added, the courtroom heard. The woman stopped sleeping with the air-conditioning on, as she would fall asleep very deeply and fail to notice if someone wished to harm her.

She said somebody wanted to kill her and her children, and said the girl needed to protect all of them.

In the 2 days leading up to the killing, closed-circuit television cameras at train channels captured her behaving erratically.

Two days before the murder, the lady entered Aljunied MRT station alone plus took the teach to Somerset. She left the train station for several minutes before returning, but tapped out again after dealing with the gantry.

She later required the train in order to Tanjong Pagar, exiting and entering once again after a few minutes.   According to court documents, she travelled in this way because she was instructed by a voice to do this.

A day prior to the murder, she got her younger child to Aljunied MRT station in the morning plus tailgated a commuter to enter the place with the four-year-old girl in her hands.

She visited Tampines MRT train station, where she tailgated another commuter to exit the train station. She behaved erratically in the area near Tampines MRT station for many hours, wandering aimlessly before sitting on the floor in the foyer associated with Tampines Mall along with her daughter for about half an hour.

According to court documents, she had been instructed by a tone of voice to look for her home in Tampines and the voice told her to not bring her old daughter along.

Because of what the voice said, the woman delivered only her youthful daughter with the girl. She left her older daughter close to the train station and requested her to keep them. The eight-year-old girl then went to her grandparents’ coffee shop nearby.


On Aug ten, 2021, the woman was in her bedroom along with her two children. Her brother, sister-in-law, niece and nephew were also in your own home, while her mothers and fathers were working in their particular coffee shop.

At some point before 11. 38am, the woman’s niece was eating breakfast within the living room when the girl heard the woman talking incoherently in Mandarin in her area, referring to names associated with Chinese historical statistics.

The woman’s relative went to her parents’ room and told her mother what the lady had heard, yet her mother stated she did not hear anything. The niece then went back to the living room to continue the girl breakfast.

The lady later heard the woman’s two children crying and moping and decided to report the woman’s rants, as she felt it might be useful if the woman were to seek medical help.

Since the woman was speaking very loudly plus incoherently, her brother went to her room to check on her. When he opened the door, he was stunned to see the victim laying motionless on the floor. There is a lot of blood, and the woman was naked and holding a pair of scissors.

Your ex brother shouted at her, and she walked towards him. He asked his loved ones to call the authorities. He saw a blood-stained knife within the room, and he quickly took it and threw it on the kitchen before shutting the door.

He took pillows to guard himself before re-entering the woman’s room. She was waving the pair of scissors, and he found her more youthful daughter hiding at the rear of the door.

He or she grabbed the girl quickly and went to their bedroom to hide together with his wife and kids. His wife the police, and he produced a phone call in order to ask his moms and dads to return home rapidly as the woman had stabbed her girl.

The police plus paramedics arrived at about noon. Two officers entered the woman’s room and saw her holding onto a pair of scissors, while her older daughter was lying down motionless on the floor.

After assessing how the woman did not create an immediate danger, the particular officers escorted her out of the bedroom.

The victim was motionless and had simply no pulse or breath. She was taken to hospital with multiple wounds on her entire body and neck, yet died later that will day despite resuscitation efforts. Her cause of death was determined to be stab injuries to her neck and torso.

The particular girl’s mother was clothed and caught.


Investigations revealed the fact that woman was suffering from schizophrenia at the time of the particular offence. It choose to go untreated for several years and worsened in severity as time progressed. At the time of the homicide, she was struggling her first psychotic episode.

The girl began hearing voices in March 2021. They started out soft and infrequent, yet became louder as well as the content more unpleasant. The voices informed her that her food, water and cooking were poisoned.

They also told her to harm herself plus her family. Particularly, the voices told her to kill her older daughter, since she was a good evil spirit that must be killed.

When needed of the incident, the woman was with the girl daughters in the girl room when the sounds again told her that her daughter has been an evil spirit that needed to be killed.

Acting on the instructions of the voices, the girl stabbed her daughter to death plus stopped only when the voices told her to prevent, the court noticed.

After this, the voices told her to consider off her clothing and the woman complied, said Deputy General public Prosecutor Teo Lu Jia. The sounds also told her in order to kill herself. Eventually, her brother came in.

Ms Teo said that the woman had been of unsound thoughts at the time of the offence and was barely aware of what was taking place. She was struggling with hallucinations and had been mentally incapacitated such that she did not understand what she was doing was wrong.

The woman is at high risk of self-harm plus requires long-term guidance and psychiatric treatment, the court noticed.

A doctor assessed the woman and said she was severely psychotic during the time of the offence plus was incapable of the actual nature of her acts. Her psychosis caused her considering and judgment to be so distorted plus out of touch along with reality that she was unable to differentiate between right plus wrong, both morally and legally.

The woman is currently suit to plead in court.

The particular prosecutor asked for the court order for the woman to be held in safe custody and for the matter to be reported to the ressortchef (umgangssprachlich).

It is undisputed that she triggered her daughter’s dying, but in the circumstances, the particular prosecution urged the particular court to acquit the woman of her murder charge based on an unsound mind.

Defence attorneys Choo Si Sen and his daughter Choo Yean Lin agreed with the prosecution’s distribution.  

“A young innocent a lot more lost. That cannot be undone, ” stated Ms Choo. “However, moving on, we hope that the (woman) can recover speedily so she can be reunited with her older parents and her youngest daughter. inch